When the width of the Strip has been reduced to half-an-inch, you
will grant, I suppose, that the area is exactly half what it was at
first—since two such Strips, laid side by side, evidently make
up the original Strip. And so, by reducing the width to a quarter-inch,
&c., we obtain a number of different areas, all Infinite alike, and
yet having finite ratios to one another: in fact, so long as the width
continues to be a finite fraction (i. e. a fraction with a
finite numerator and denominator) of an inch, the area continues to be
an Infinity of the same order as the original Strip. (It seems
obvious that Infinities of the same order have finite ratios to
one another, and that any one of them can be so multiplied, by a finite
number, as to exceed any other.)
But this narrowing process may be continued until the two Lines
absolutely coincide: and what then becomes of the area?
It cannot be denied that it is then Zero.
Now I have ventured (see p. 2) to lay it down, as an Axiom, that, when
a Magnitude varies continuously, and has changed from a certain
value to a certain other value, it must have passed through every
intermediate value. And what intermediate values do we find between
an Infinite Area and Zero?[Pg 45] Surely every Finite Area, that can
be named, lies between them? The Reader can, if he likes, part company
with me at this point: but to my Reason it seems absolutely
clear—first, that the Strip does diminish continuously, and not
'per saltum'; and secondly, that its area has, at some time or
other during the process, every conceivable finite value. At one
time, for instance, it contains a square-mile: and, rather later in its
career, it is reduced to a single square-inch.
Let us contemplate it in this last-named condition. Its length? As
Infinite, clearly, as it was at first. Its Area? One square-inch,
undoubtedly. And what is its width?
Can you, oh gentle Reader, find any reasonable answer to this question,
except the following? "Its width is infinitely small—having, in
fact, exactly the same relation to a linear inch which that linear inch
has to an infinite Line."
If this be so (and I see no way out of it), we have found two
Magnitudes, both linear, neither of them infinite, and yet such that
no finite multiple of the lesser can possibly exceed the greater.
They are, in fact, not of the same order; one of them being
Finite, and the other an Infinitesimal of the first order.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account