Dao De Jing: A Minimalist Translation — John Shaqi
Dao De Jing: A Minimalist TranslationLaozi
Philosophy
Dao De Jing: A Minimalist Translation
Laozi
Philosophy, Chinese; Taoism -- Sacred books
“Sin” of course has very negative religious connotations in
the West, while “crime” and “vice” also have stronger negative associations
than “fault”.
But there are other, even more
significant ways in which the translator’s choices affect the result.
Because of the many (sometimes unrelated) possible meanings of each Chinese
symbol, it is possible to come up with multiple translations of the exact same
sentence that are completely different in meaning! For example, in
chapter 41, there is a line : 大 方 無 隅
where 方 can mean both
“region” and “square”, while 隅
can be “border” or “corner”, so both of these are valid translations :
The greatest region is without
borders.
The greatest square is without
corners.
And in chapter 45 : 大 巧 若 拙 where 巧 can be “skillful” or “clever”, and 拙 can mean “stupid” or
“clumsy”, both of these are equally likely :
Great skillfulness seems clumsy.
Great cleverness seems stupid.
Finally, even when there is no
ambiguity about the meaning of the individual symbols, it sometimes hard to determine
what overall meaning was intended. From chapter 35, there is a line : 道 之 出 言 淡 兮 in
which the first four symbols literally mean “words of Dao”, but does this mean
“talking about Dao” or “the words that come out of Dao”? It can be argued
both ways due to subtleties in the meanings of the symbols, but there is a
tremendous difference in meaning between the two translations.
In addition, there are a few symbols whose modern English
meanings just don’t make sense within the context of the sentence, probably due
either to transcription errors or changes in meaning over the millennia.
The English words used for these symbols are usually selected according to
context.
==============================================================
Common Terms
Because the translation itself is meant to involve minimal
interpretation and explanation, some of the words and phrases that are used
repeatedly need to be discussed beforehand for clarity. Keep in mind that
volumes have been written about some of these concepts – these are just brief
summaries for the reader new to Daoism.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account