Debate on birth control. Margaret Sanger and Winter Russell — John Shaqi
Debate on birth control. Margaret Sanger and Winter RussellSanger, Margaret
History
Debate on birth control. Margaret Sanger and Winter Russell
Sanger, Margaret
Birth control -- Moral and ethical aspects
Now we look upon all these things just about in the same way. We try to
palliate most all of them. Take one instance—our immigration laws. The
United States Government makes the most rigid laws. It scans over the
vessels carefully to see that no one should enter who is an idiot, who
is insane, and who is a pauper. They see to it that anyone who enters is
not an idiot, is not insane and is not a pauper. They make those rigid
laws and rules for those who shall come in, but after you are once on
the inside, you can produce and reproduce and repopulate the earth with
syphilitic and diseased and insane people as far as the government is
concerned. This is the short-sighted side of our whole life. We are very
generous and sympathetic but we are oversentimental, and the time has
come to use our minds and to apply our intelligence to life and to the
conditions of life as we find them today.
Now Mr. Russell has said some things that are very interesting to me. He
tells us that we cannot have pleasure without pain. It is a man who is
speaking. (Laughter and applause.) It is very peculiar that Nature only
works on the one side of the human family when it comes to that law. She
applies all the pain to the woman. It is absurd—a perfectly absurd
argument in the face of rational intelligence (applause) to talk about
marriage being for one purpose.
Now I claim—and I differ with Mr. Russell on that—I claim that the sex
relationship has distinctly two functions. It has its love function and
it has its maternal and paternal function. One is quite independent of
the other, and one is just as moral as the other, and if it were not so,
then the laws of this country ought to divorce the woman who is not able
to have children. Absolutely! And we know it does not. We know that the
time the children are created that there is not 1 percent of humanity
that is born or created with that thought in mind. Very few people think
at the time of creation that they are going to create. Most of us are
brought into the world by accident and that is exactly what birth
control is going to change. That is going to make humanity a conscious
and voluntary thing.
When we talk of race suicide, it would take almost a whole afternoon to
tell you how futile that argument is. We know perfectly well, those of
us who have studied the question that in those countries where birth
control knowledge has been at the disposal of the people that, although
the birth rate has gone down, that the death rate has also gone down.
Consequently the population has been accelerated and there has been a
better population because it has been a better and healthier population.
If Mr. Russell wants to talk about the race and does not want race
suicide he had better come over quickly to the ranks of birth control.
(Applause.)
Winter Russell
SECOND SPEECH
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account