Deficiency and Delinquency: An Interpretation of Mental TestingMiner, James Burt
Science
Deficiency and Delinquency: An Interpretation of Mental Testing
Miner, James Burt
Children with mental disabilities; Juvenile delinquents; Mentally ill offenders; Psychological tests
The Children's Bureau in the U. S. Department of Labor in 1915 made a
census of the number of “mental defectives” in the District of Columbia.
The census included only those whom we have termed feeble-minded. The
report states that 798 individuals, 0.24% of the population, were found
to be “in need of institutional treatment; and the number reported,
allowing for the margin of error in omission and inclusion, is probably
a fair representation of the number in the District who should have
custodial care” (_88_, p. 13). Over a quarter of the population of the
District is colored. The census was taken in connection with plans for
immediate care. The same Bureau also made in 1915 and 1916 a Social
Study of Mental Defectives in New Castle County, Delaware.[6] This
county had a population of 131,670 and the survey disclosed 212
“positive cases of mental defect” and 361 “questionable cases,” a total
of 0.44% of the general population in this county. Among the positive
cases, 82.5% were in need of public supervision or institutional care.
Among the questionable cases, information was obtained about only 175,
and 165 of these were either in institutions, delinquent or
uncontrollable, or living in homes where proper care and safeguarding
were impossible.
Two other important attempts to enumerate carefully all the
feeble-minded in definite areas in the United States have been made in
recent years. Lapeer County, Mich., was chosen for such a study, as it
was of average size and contained no large city. The census as reported
in 1914, showed 36 feeble-minded from that county in the state
institution and 116 others living in the county, a total of 1 from every
171 inhabitants (_145_). A special children's commission was appointed
by the state of New Hampshire to investigate the welfare of dependent,
defective and delinquent children. Its report in 1914 contained a
section by its chairman, Mrs. Lilian C. Streeter, on feeble-mindedness
(_40_). This comes the nearest to a complete enumeration for an entire
state which has ever been attempted. The commission tested with the
Binet scale the inmates of the State Hospital for the Insane, the County
Farms, the State Industrial School and the Orphanages within the state.
The borderline which it used for the scale was high. It counted all
those testing three or more years retarded and under XII as
feeble-minded. Taking its figures as they stand we find that they listed
947 as feeble-minded in institutions and 2,019 outside, a total of 0.69%
of the inhabitants of the state. Outside the institutions the commission
sent a questionnaire to all school superintendents and to chairmen of
school boards, physicians, overseers of the poor, county commissioners,
probation and truant officers, district nurses and charity workers
throughout the state, by which means they listed 792 additional cases.
This questionnaire gave the following description of the type of case it
was trying to list as feeble-minded.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account