Dialogue; English literature -- History and criticism
a passage of his which bears on the whole subject, and shows both his
method and the absolute consciousness with which he employed it――to
say nothing of the shameless candour with which he laughs at his own
trick. Corporal Trim is discoursing to his fellow servants on the death
of Tristram’s brother, Master Bobby. ‘Are we not here now?’ continued
the Corporal (striking the end of his stick perpendicularly upon the
floor, so as to give an emblem of health and stability) ‘and’ (dropping
his hat upon the ground) ‘gone in a minute?’ Then Sterne digresses, and
repeats――as his manner is. But he comes back――and is good enough to
explain: ‘Let us only carry back our minds to the mortality of Trim’s
hat,’ he says. ‘Are we not here now――and gone in a moment? There was
nothing in the sentence――’twas one of your self-evident truths we have
the advantage of hearing every day: and if Trim had not trusted more
to his hat than to his head, he had made nothing at all of it.’ And
he proceeds: ‘Ten thousand and ten thousand times ten thousand (for
matter and motion are infinite) are the ways by which a hat may be
dropped on the ground without any effect. Had he flung it, or thrown
it, or cast it, or skimmed it, or squirted it, or let it slip or fall
in any possible direction under heaven――had he dropped it like a goose,
like a puppy, like an ass――or in doing it or even after he had done
it, had looked like a fool, like a ninny, like a nincompoop――it had
failed, and the effect upon the heart had been lost.’ And he ends――most
justifiably――‘Meditate, I beseech you, upon Trim’s hat!’ Trim’s hat
may certainly stand as an instance of the value of stage-directions to
novel dialogue.
Returning to actually spoken words――the real talk between the
interlocutors――we may note the great adaptability and elasticity of
the dialogue form. The hesitation, the aposiopesis, the interruption,
are all ready and flexible devices, apt to convey hints, innuendoes,
doubts, objections, apt to convey the sense of a balance inclining
now this way, now that, to show one mind feeling its way towards a
knowledge of the other, while sedulously guarding its own secrets. Or
you may seek the broader effects of comedy with the sudden betrayal
of irreconcilable divergence, or of an agreement as complete as it is
paradoxical, or of the mutual helplessness which results from total
misunderstanding of the one by the other, or, finally, of the well-worn
but still effective device――a favourite one in the theatre――of two
people talking at cross-purposes, one meaning one thing, the other a
different one, and the pair arriving at an harmonious agreement from
utterly inharmonious premises――the false accord of a hundred scenes of
comedy.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account