Diversions of a NaturalistLankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
History
Diversions of a Naturalist
Lankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
Natural history
A celebrated case to which Darwin attached importance was that of Lord
Morton's mare, reported to the Royal Society in 1820. This mare, after
bearing a hybrid by a quagga (a striped equine related to the zebra)
produced, to a black Arabian horse, three foals showing a number of
stripes, and in one of them more stripes were present than in the
quagga hybrid. This seems at first sight strong evidence in favour
of "infection" of the mare by the early quagga mate. But it appears
that stripes are frequently seen in high-caste Arab horses, and colts
cross-bred from such and other breeds of horse sometimes present far
more distinct bars across the legs and other zebra-like markings than
were seen in the late offspring of Lord Morton's Arabian mare. The fact
appears to be that all the living species of the horse family (horses,
asses, quaggas, and zebras) are descended from an ancestry of "striped"
equines, and are liable occasionally to "throw back" to their striped
ancestry, more or less.
Professor Cossar Ewart determined some years ago to submit the matter
to direct experiment, and has related his results in a book ("The
Penicuik Experiments," 1899). The South African equine called the
quagga, which was that used by Lord Morton, having become extinct,
Professor Ewart made use of a richly striped Burchell's zebra. Thirty
mares put to this animal produced seventeen hybrids, and subsequently
these mares, put to horse-stallions, produced twenty pure-bred foals.
All the zebra hybrids were richly and very distinctly striped. Of the
twenty later pure-bred horse-foals from the same mares three only
presented stripe-like markings at birth, and these were few and
indistinct. They disappeared when the foal's coat was shed. Their
mothers were Highland mares. But the value of the faint striping in
these three instances as evidence in support of telegony is at once
destroyed by the fact that Professor Ewart obtained at the same time
pure-bred foals from similar Highland mares which had never seen a
zebra. Two of these pure-bred Highland foals showed stripes at birth,
and one acquired stripes later; and further, whilst the stripes on the
foals born after hybrids had been produced by their mothers disappeared
with the foal's coat, the stripes on the three pure-bred colts whose
mothers had never been near a zebra persisted for a longer period.
Similar experiments confirmed these results, showing that traces of
striping are no more likely to occur on the offspring of a mare which
has previously produced a mule with a zebra or an ass, than on one
whose dam has neither seen nor been near to a zebra or an ass. Lord
Morton's case thus falls to the ground.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account