The writer, having had occasion in his professional practice to study
quite carefully the subject of ground waters, and their percolation
or flow through different classes of materials and under varying
conditions, is of the opinion that rarely does the cross-section of
a stream-channel, filled with sand, gravel and debris, present, even
approximately, a homogeneous or uniform mass; and that there are,
almost without exception, strata of material much coarser and more
porous than the general average. In other words, that it is extremely
difficult to arrive at a uniformity coefficient. It is unwise to place
much reliance upon an estimated flow where this is the case. The
formula may be used with confidence where the layers are artificially
made, and where there is no uncertainty regarding the uniform character
of the material. In most natural channels there are distinct lines
of flow, and under considerable hydrostatic head or pressure these
lines of flow would surely enlarge. There is a wide difference between
permissible and dangerously excessive percolation through an earth
embankment. The local features, economical considerations and magnitude
of the risks, all bear upon this question and must be considered for
each particular case.
It is of interest to compare the estimated cost of the three designs
proposed for the Bohio Dam, based upon the same unit prices, as follows:
French Engineers’ design $3,500,000
Isthmian Canal Commissioners’ design 8,000,000
Mr. Morison’s design 2,500,000
No comments will be made upon these figures, further than to remark
that the successful building of a stable dam, accomplished by the use
of an excessive quantity of materials and at a cost beyond reasonable
requirements, is mainly instructive as illustrating “how not to do it.”
It is creditable to execute substantial works at a reasonable cost,
but it reflects no credit upon any one to construct them regardless of
expense.
Combined Rock-fill and Earth Dam.
Fig. 30 shows a section of the Upper Pecos River Dam near Eddy, N. M.
This dam is quite fully described by Mr. Jas. D. Schuyler, in his
recent book on “Reservoirs for Irrigation, Water-Power and Domestic
Water-Supply,” and need not be mentioned in this paper, further than
to call attention to the combination of rock-fill and earth which
constitutes its particular type of construction. This type of dam is
believed to be for many localities a very good one, but up to the
present time has only been adopted for dams of moderate height, under
60 ft.
The San Leandro Dam, California.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account