England's Case Against Home RuleDicey, A. V. (Albert Venn)
History
England's Case Against Home Rule
Dicey, A. V. (Albert Venn)
Home rule -- Ireland
_"C'est que, pour organiser en Irlande un gouvernement central puissant,
il faudrait de plus en plus resserrer le lien d'union qui attache
l'Irlande a l'Angleterre, rapprocher le plus possible Dublin de Londres,
et faire de l'Irlande un comte anglais._
* * * * *
_"On ne conteste point que l'Irlande ait besoin d'un gouvernement
special; et s'il y a necessite de la soumettre a un regime legislatif
autre que celui de l'Angleterre, il faut bien aussi des agents
particuliers pour appliquer des regles differentes d'administration.
Mais, ceci etant admis, l'on ne voit pas ce qui aujourd'hui empecherait
de placer le siege du gouvernement irlandais dans la premiere ville de
l'empire britannique._
* * * * *
_"La reforme de la vice-royaute et l'abolition des administrations
locales d'Irlande ne sont, sans doute, que des changements de forme.
Mais ce sont des moyens pratiques indispensables pour executer les
reformes politiques dont ce pays a besoin. Il faut que, pendant la
periode de transition ou se trouve l'Irlande, ceux qui la gouvernent
soient places absolument en dehors d'elle, de ses moeurs, de ses
passions; il faut que son gouvernement cesse completement d'etre
irlandais; il faut qu'il soit entierement, non pas anglais, mais remis a
des Anglais."_--2 De Beaumont, _l'Irlande, Sociale, Politique et
Religieuse_, pp. 124-129
CHAPTER III.
STRENGTH OF THE HOME RULE MOVEMENT IN ENGLAND.
[Sidenote: Strength of movement.]
A dispassionate observer will easily convince himself that in Great
Britain the movement in favour of Home Rule is stronger than is believed
by its opponents. Patent facts show that this is so. In 1880 no single
English statesman had avowed himself its supporter; not fifty English or
Scotch members of Parliament could have been found to vote for an
enquiry into the admissibility of Mr. Parnell's policy. It may well be
doubted whether at that date ten British constituencies would have
returned to Parliament representatives pledged to grant Ireland a
separate legislature. Contrast this state of things with the present
condition of affairs. England has indeed pronounced decisively against
any tampering with the Act of Union, but the leading statesman of the
day has avowed himself a Home Ruler; he is supported by eminent
colleagues, and by nearly two hundred representatives of British
constituencies. Scotland and Wales on the whole favour the policy of
separation, and if, as has been roughly computed, of the electors of
the United Kingdom, 1,316,327 have voted in support of the Union, the
same computation shows that 1,238,342 are, to say the least, indifferent
to its maintenance. These are facts which tell their own tale. The Home
Rule movement has waxed strong. What is in England the source of its
strength, and what are the arguments in its support relied upon by its
English advocates?
[Sidenote: Source of its strength.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account