English Translations from the Greek: A Bibliographical SurveyFoster, Finley Melville Kendall
General
English Translations from the Greek: A Bibliographical Survey
Foster, Finley Melville Kendall
Greek literature -- Translations into English -- Bibliography; Thesis (Ph. D.)
As the publication of “classical libraries” is a nineteenth century
development, so the introduction of schoolboy helps began with the early
years of the century. The work of T. W. C. Edwards in the twenties and
thirties was intended for schoolboy consumption. At the same time one or
more persons hid behind the all‐inclusive authorship of "Graduate of the
University of Oxford" to produce literal translations of the works of the
dramatists. In the middle of the century much of the work of Doctor J. A.
Giles was done to help the schoolboy over hard places. In 1870 and the
following years a new series of translations of the dramatists was brought
out by a “First‐Class Man of Balliol College.” Roscoe Mongan, whose
translations were to a large extent published in _Kelly’s Keys to the
Classics_, began his work in 1878. These translations went over the ground
covered by his predecessors, and spread out into history, epic and
philosophy. Evidently the schoolboys of his time found them very useful,
for many of them were reprinted within a few years.
During the early eighties the “First‐Class Man of Balliol College”
reappeared with a translation of Herodotus book by book. From this time
until the outbreak of the present war there was a steady output of these
utilitarian translations. G. F. H. Sykes, J. H. Haydon, A. H. Allcroft, J.
A. Prout, F. G. Plaistowe, E. S. Crooke, J. Thompson, B. J. Hayes, H.
Hailstone, T. R. Mills, W. H. Balgarnie, J. F. Stout, and others who did
only one or two books, made their translations with the student of the
language as their reading public. Some of these translations appeared in
the _University Tutorial Series_, a collection of books in which the text,
translations, notes, vocabulary, difficult parsings, and test papers were
published.
The work of these men, quantitatively at least, is an important factor in
the history of Greek translation. Between 1850 and 1870 only eleven
translations of this type were published; between the years 1870 and 1910,
however, at least two hundred and eleven schoolboy helps were published.
The following table gives the minimum figures for this kind of translation
during these years.
1870‐1879=26
1880‐1889=62
1890‐1899=86
1900‐1909=37
The falling off in the first decade of the twentieth century may be due to
two causes: first, the decrease in the number of students of Greek in the
schools, which was the result of the great opposition stirred up in the
latter part of the nineteenth century by the advocates of a more practical
education; and, secondly, the ample production of the decade preceding
filled the market and plentifully supplied the demand. I have set forth
here these figures in regard to the schoolboy translation because I doubt
whether the extent of that type of work has been realized by any except
the competing publishers. To no small degree has the total of translations
in the latter part of the nineteenth century been increased by this type
of publication.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account