English Verse: Specimens Illustrating its Principles and HistoryAlden, Raymond MacDonald
General
English Verse: Specimens Illustrating its Principles and History
Alden, Raymond MacDonald
English language -- Versification; English poetry
Ten Brink calls attention to the possibility of the influence upon
Chaucer's couplet of the Italian hendecasyllabic verse. The
_Compleynte to Pitee_, it is true, was written probably before the
Italian journey of 1372-1373; but in Italy the "full significance"
of the metre may have become clear to Chaucer. "After that journey
the heroic verse appears almost exclusively as his poetic
instrument.... Of still greater significance is the fact that
Chaucer's heroic verse differs from the French decasyllabic in all
the particulars in which the Italian hendecasyllabic departs from
the common source, and approaches the verse of Dante and Boccaccio
as closely as the metre of a Germanic language can approach a
Romance metre. It may be added also that the heroic verse in the
_Compleynte to Pitee_ stands nearer the French decasyllabic than
that of the _Troilus_ or the _Canterbury Tales_."
Dr. Lewis, on the other hand, in _The Foreign Sources of English
Versification_, would minimize the foreign sources of Chaucer's
couplet. Not only the unaccentual character of the French verse is
opposed to the theory of the French source, but also, he believes,
the fixed cesura. "In the English verse there is no such thing:
indeed there is no cesura at all, in the French sense of the
word.... Schipper relegates to a foot-note the suggestion that our
heroic verse may have originated in a different way, either through
an abridgment of the alexandrine or through an extension of the
four-foot line. This is of course more nearly the true view, but it
is entirely immaterial which of the last two explanations we hit
upon. Accentual verses of four, six, and seven feet were already
familiar long before Chaucer's time. They exhibited a more or less
regular alternation of arsis and thesis. To devise a verse which
should be essentially the same in principle, but should have five
accents instead of four, six, or seven, was a task that Chaucer's
genius might well achieve unaided" (pp. 98, 99).
It is quite possible that a combination of all these views may be
nearest the truth. The objection to the French influence on the
ground of the syllabic (non-accentual) quality of the French verse
does not seem to be serious, since any imitation of French verse by
an Englishman would be likely to take on the accentual form; and,
that once done, the need for the fixed cesura would vanish. But it
is worth while to emphasize the fact that the genius of English
verse was not so averse to the formation of a decasyllabic
five-stress line as to make it a serious innovation. This view is
further emphasized by the next specimen.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account