American essays -- 19th century; Literature -- History and criticism
Is this true, I wonder, and are our supersensitive babies reared perforce
on the optimistic version of Red Riding Hood, where the wolf is cut
open by the woodman, and the little girl and her grandmother jump out,
safe and sound? Their New England champion speaks of the “intolerable
misery”—a very strong phrase—which he suffered in infancy from having
his nurse tell him of the Babes in the Wood; while the Scriptural
stories were apparently every whit as unbearable and heart-breaking. “I
remember,” he says, “two children, strong, brave man and woman now, who
in righteous rage plucked the Slaughter of the Innocents out from the
family Bible.” This was a radical measure, to say the least, and if many
little boys and girls started in to expurgate, the Scriptures in such
liberal fashion, the holy book would soon present a sadly mutilated
appearance. Moreover, it seems to me that such an anecdote, narrated
with admirable assurance, reveals very painfully the lack of a fine
and delicate spirituality in the religious training of children; of
that grace and distinction which are akin to saintship, and are united
so charmingly in those to whom truth has been inseparably associated
with beauty. There is a painting by Ghirlandaio hanging over the altar
in the chapel of the Foundling Asylum in Florence. It represents the
Adoration of the Magi, and kneeling by the side of the Wise Men is a
little group of the Holy Innocents, their tiny garments stained with
blood, their hands clasped in prayer; while the Divine Child turns from
his mother’s embraces, and from the kings’ rich gifts to greet the little
companions who have yielded up their spotless lives for him. Now, surely
those lean, brown Florentine orphans, who have always before their eyes
this beautiful and tender picture, absorb through it alone a religious
sentiment unfelt by American children who are familiar only with the ugly
and inane prints of American Sunday-schools, in which I have known the
line, “My soul doth magnify the Lord,” to be illustrated by a man with
a magnifying-glass in his hand. Possibly our Sunday-school scholars,
being more accurately instructed as to dates, could inform the little
Florentines that the Innocents were not slaughtered until after the Magi
had returned to the East. But no child who had looked day after day upon
Ghirlandaio’s lovely picture—more appealing in its pathos than Holman
Hunt’s brilliant and jocund Triumph of the Innocents—could desire to
pluck “in righteous rage” that chapter from the Bible. He would have at
least some dim and imperfect conception of the spiritual meaning, the
spiritual joy, which underlie the pain and horror of the story.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account