So much needs to be said by way of charge and speculation in order
to clear the air. If I write with some excitement, it is no more
than the sight of the tumble from great-worded, great deeded 1918
to the indifferent, self-regarding, and a little cynical present
may account for. Certainly in our national past idealism has not
been an illusion, although it was often emotional. Nor, in sober
fact, do I doubt the essential idealism of the normal American mind,
especially that American mind which inherits the optimism and the
liberal instincts of our forefathers. I am merely curious as to the
exact nature of that idealism as it exists, and plays strange tricks,
to-day. It seems to be a quality more resembling energy than a moral
characteristic like virtue or vice. It seems, as one thinks over these
recent manifestations, to be a blend of physical virility and nervous
sensitiveness, good or bad, active or inactive, according to the
condition and environment of the patient. Stir him, and it becomes
active, beneficent, altruistic. Stir him further, and it may become
sentimental, with symptoms of hysteria. Relax the pressure, and it
drops into desuetude. These are the habits of American idealism, and
I doubt whether more can be said of them except by way of further
description. But there must be some thoughts, some ideas behind to
account for these vagaries. There must be reasons why Americans
idealize more readily than other nations, and why, just now at least,
they so easily tire of their idealizing.
Neither the scope of these pages nor my knowledge permits me to trace
the history of American thinking and feeling, to say, as the historians
some day must, what elements came from Europe, what modifications are
due to pioneer environment, racial mixture, and centuries of unchecked
material development. But tentatively, and with all modesty, one may
at least seek for light. I find that two great figures of our national
youth and the ways of thinking they represented most help me to
understand the strengths and the weaknesses of American idealism, help
to an understanding of the phenomena of 1917-20.
The first is Jonathan Edwards, theologian of international importance,
leader of the great spiritual revival of mid-eighteenth century New
England, missionary to the Indians, president of Princeton, author of
works so widely read that even now no farm-house garret in New England
but will yield a sermon or two, a treatise on original sin, or his
epochal essay on the freedom of the will.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account