Forgers and ForgeriesConstable, W. G. (William George)
History
Forgers and Forgeries
Constable, W. G. (William George)
Art -- Forgeries
All the examples of forgery so far mentioned are of the manufactured
type, however little work may have been expended on them. In this they
differ entirely from the forgeries which depend wholly on
misrepresentation, a genuine article of one kind being passed off as of
another, without any physical change. It is not usual to brand such
things as forgeries, and legally they are not so regarded; but morally,
in that something is made to appear what it is not, they seem to be
truly forgeries.
[Illustration: ABOVE: A forgery (partly cleaned for examination) of
a fifteenth-century Florentine portrait, compared with a genuine
example (BELOW). The forgery is on an old panel, but was finally
proved false by the presence of titanium white, a twentieth-century
pigment.]
[Illustration: (genuine example)]
A simple and widespread means of falsifying in this way is a certificate
of authorship and genuineness. Sometimes, the writers of these are of
the highest competence and probity. These two qualities are not always
combined, however; and the certificate then becomes either intentionally
or innocently misleading. Unfortunately, most certificates are written
for a fee, and there is always temptation for the writer to err on the
side of pleasing his employer; while there is no question that sometimes
certificates have been given deliberately to defraud. Moreover, forged
certificates bearing reputable names are not unknown, a special variety
being the stringing together of words from a genuine letter, with all
qualifying or negative phrases omitted. There is, however, a more
insidious method of giving a certificate, that of publication of an
object in a reliable journal. Editors are generally careful enough; but
they are defenseless in the face of a plausible case put forward by a
name of some reputation, especially when the passage relating to the
object is included in a more general context. This kind of certification
is particularly difficult to cope with, since such articles will
continue to be cited in later publications, perhaps mainly to controvert
them but nevertheless renewing their availability for dishonest
purposes.
Construction of false pedigrees is another means of misrepresentation,
much used in the case of copies or versions. Sometimes, a pedigree is
completely false, naming imaginary former owners whose existence cannot
be proved but equally cannot be disproved. Sometimes, such history as
the object may have is grafted onto that of another and accepted
version, so that the two may become confused. A special case of this is
the planting out of objects in houses whose owners are ready, for a
consideration, to describe them as having descended in the family, or
even as having been bought from the maker by an ancestor.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account