Forgers and ForgeriesConstable, W. G. (William George)
History
Forgers and Forgeries
Constable, W. G. (William George)
Art -- Forgeries
The skill, ingenuity, and knowledge of the forger and of those who
exploit his work, are opposed to the skill, ingenuity, and knowledge of
the collector and the learned world. The unaided human eye, if it has a
trained and well-informed mind behind it, can go a long way in detecting
forgeries. It is surprising how forgetful, careless, or ignorant a
forger can be. He may employ materials whose inconsistency with the
period to which his work claims to belong can be seen even by the
unaided eye. More common is the introduction of such things as types and
details of costume, or the use of coats of arms, that are later than the
alleged date of the work. All such evidence, however, needs scrutiny,
since it may simply be a case of later additions to a genuine object.
More useful, therefore, may be tracking down the source of a forger’s
borrowings. If, for example, these at first sight seem to come from an
original work, but follow much more closely the variations from that
original in a later copy or engraving, the conclusion is obvious. Again,
investigation of pedigrees, checking of literary references, searching
through exhibition records, may all reveal suspicious or occasionally
damning evidence of falsified history.
[Illustration: ABOVE: A forgery of a portrait by Cranach, and
(BELOW) a genuine example. A style forgery, skillful, but coarser
than an original.]
[Illustration: (genuine example)]
To tests based on observation and historical verification, we must add
those mainly dependent on feeling. For the sensitive and trained
observer, a number of indefinable characteristics will “add up” to a
definite conviction of genuine or false. Qualities of surface and
handling, subtleties in color and in the definition of form, the degree
of unity in conception and treatment, and the emotional character of the
work are among the things which influence such decisions. Thus, a copy,
however exact, may reveal itself as lacking the coherence and the
feeling which inspired the original; and the most skillful imitation of
some older work may be recognized as a creation of its own time. Nobody
can completely divorce himself from the prevailing thoughts, opinions,
assumptions, feelings, and standards of his own period; and inevitably
these will color whatever he produces, whether he be a forger or an
original artist.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account