Civil disobedience -- India; India -- Politics and government -- 1919-1947
But some people say that it is immoral from the point of view of
non-co-operation, because it involves an idea of destruction. The work of
non-co-operation according to these,--I have the highest reverence for
them,--is only to build our national life ignoring altogether the
existence of the Bureaucracy. It may be an honest ideal, and, logically
speaking, it may be the inner meaning of non-co-operation. But the
non-co-operation which the Congress has followed is not so logical and I
claim that if the principle of non-co-operation is to be advanced as a
test of my programme, let it be the same principle which the Congress has
accepted, adopted and applied. As I have already said, that principle
countenance destruction as well as creation. As a matter of fact
circumstanced as we are with Bureaucracy to the right and the Bureaucracy
to the left Bureaucracy all around us, it is impossible to create without
destroying: nor must it be forgotten that if we break, it is only that we
may build.
It has also been suggested that the very entry into the Council is
inconsistent with the ideal of non-co-operation. I confess I do not
understand the argument. Supposing the Congress had sanctioned an armed
insurrection could it be argued that entry into the fort of the
Bureaucracy is inconsistent with the principle of non-co-operation? Surely
the charge of inconsistency must depend on the object of the entry. An
advancing army does not co-operate with the enemy when it marches into
the enemy's territory. Co-operation must therefore depend on the object
with which such entry is made. The argument if analysed comes to this,
that whenever the phrase entry into Councils is used it calls up the
association of co-operation, and then the mere idea of this entry
is proclaimed to be inconsistent with non-co-operation. But this
is the familiar logical fallacy of our terms. Entry into the
Councils to co-operate with the Government and entry into the
Councils to non-co-operate with the Government are two terms and two
different propositions. The former is inconsistent with the idea of
non-co-operation, the latter is absolutely consistent with that very idea.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account