From Ritual to RomanceWeston, Jessie L. (Jessie Laidlay)
Religion
From Ritual to Romance
Weston, Jessie L. (Jessie Laidlay)
Grail -- Legends -- History and criticism; Romances -- History and criticism
In _Diû Crône_ alone, where the Grail-bearer and her maidens are the
sole living beings in an abode of the Dead, is any explanation of the
‘Weeping Women’ attempted, but an interpolated passage in the Heralds’
College MS. of the _Perceval_ states that when the Quest is achieved,
the hero shall learn the cause of the maiden’s grief, and also the
explanation of the Dead Knight upon the bier:
“del graal q’vient aprés
E purquei plure tut adés
La pucele qui le sustient
De la biere qu’aprés vient
Savera la vérité adonques
Ceo que nul ne pot saveir onques
Pur nule rien qui avenist.”
fo. 180vo-181.
Of course in the _Perceval_ there is neither a Weeping Maiden, nor a
Bier, and the passage must therefore be either an unintelligent
addition by a scribe familiar with the _Gawain_ versions, or an
interpolation from a source which did contain the features in question.
So far as the texts at our disposal are concerned, both features belong
exclusively to the _Gawain_, and not to the _Perceval_ Quest. The
interpolation is significant as it indicates a surviving sense of the
importance of this feature.
In the _Perlesvaus_ we have the curious detail of a maiden who has lost
her hair as a result of the hero’s failure to ask the question, and the
consequent sickness of the Fisher King. The occurrence of this detail
may be purely fortuitous, but at the same time it is admissible to
point out that the Adonis cults do provide us with a parallel in the
enforced loss of hair by the women taking part in these rites, while no
explanation of this curious feature has so far as I am aware been
suggested by critics of the text.[30]
We may also note the fact that the Grail castle is always situated in
the close vicinity of water, either on or near the sea, or on the banks
of an important river. In two cases the final home of the Grail is in a
monastery situated upon an island. The presence of water, either sea,
or river, is an important feature in the Adonis cult, the effigy of the
dead god being, not buried in the earth, but thrown into the water.[31]
It will thus be seen that, in suggesting a form of Nature worship,
analogous to this well-known cult, as the possible ultimate source from
which the incidents and _mise-en-scène_ of the Grail stories were
derived, we are relying not upon an isolated parallel, but upon a group
of parallels, which alike in incident and intention offer, not merely a
resemblance to, but also an explanation of, the perplexing problems of
the Grail literature. We must now consider the question whether
incidents so remote in time may fairly and justly be utilized in this
manner.
CHAPTER V
Medieval and Modern Forms of Nature Ritual
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account