From Ritual to RomanceWeston, Jessie L. (Jessie Laidlay)
Religion
From Ritual to Romance
Weston, Jessie L. (Jessie Laidlay)
Grail -- Legends -- History and criticism; Romances -- History and criticism
“Paul I had as my guide,
Faith however always went ahead and set before me as food a _Fish_ from
a _Fountain_, a huge one, a clean one,
Which a _Holy Virgin_ has _caught_.
This she gave to the friends ever to eat as food,
Having good _Wine_, and offering it watered together with _Bread_.
Aberkios had this engraved when 72 years of age in truth.
_Whoever can understand this_ let him pray for Aberkios.”
Eisler (I am here quoting from the Quest article) remarks, “As the last
line of our quotation gives us quite plainly to understand, a number of
words which we have italicized are obviously used in an unusual,
metaphorical, sense, that is to say as terms of the Christian Mystery
language.” While Harnack, admitting that the Christian character of the
text is indisputable, adds significantly: “_aber das Christentum der
Grosskirche ist es nicht_.”
Thus it is possible that, to the various points of doubtful orthodoxy
which scholars have noted as characteristic of the Grail romances,
Borron’s Fish-meal should also be added.
Should it be objected that the dependence of a medieval romance upon a
Jewish tradition of such antiquity is scarcely probable, I would draw
attention to the _Voyage of Saint Brandan_, where the monks, during
their prolonged wanderings, annually ‘kept their Resurrection,’ _i.e._,
celebrate their Easter Mass, on the back of a great Fish.[43] On their
first meeting with this monster Saint Brandan tells them it is the
greatest of all fishes, and is named Jastoni, a name which bears a
curious resemblance to the Jhasa of the Indian tradition cited
above.[44] In this last instance the connection of the Fish with life,
renewed and sustained, is undeniable.
The original source of such a symbol is most probably to be found in
the belief, referred to in a previous chapter,[45] that all life comes
from the water, but that a more sensual and less abstract idea was also
operative appears from the close connection of the Fish with the
goddess Astarte or Atargatis, a connection here shared by the Dove.
Cumont, in his _Les Religions Orientales dans le Paganisme Romain_,
says: “Two animals were held in general reverence, namely, Dove and
Fish. Countless flocks of Doves greeted the traveller when he stepped
on shore at Askalon, and in the outer courts of all the temples of
Astarte one might see the flutter of their white wings. The Fish were
preserved in ponds near to the Temple, and superstitious dread forbade
their capture, for the goddess punished such sacrilege, smiting the
offender with ulcers and tumours.”[46]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account