Bhagavadgita; Christianity and other religions -- Hinduism; Hinduism
This is Telang’s translation of two very difficult, yet very
instructive phrases. In the _Gītā_ the word _prakriti_ is used, first
for the primeval matter of the Sānkhya system (III, 27; 29; IX, 8, 10,
12; XIII, 19, 20, 23, 29), and secondly for the primeval matter of
personal character, each man’s natural disposition (III, 33; VII, 20;
XI, 51; XVIII, 59). There is then a third class of passages in which
the word is used in the Sānkhyan sense, but, _by the addition of a
personal pronoun_, _prakriti_ is made to belong to Krishna personally
(VII, 4, 5; IX, 7, 13). Here we have one of the devices our author
employed to give the great old phrases a vivid personal colouring. Now
such a phrase as “my prakriti” is already ambiguous; so we are not
surprised to meet with two passages, in which it is impossible to tell
whether the meaning is metaphysical or ethical (IV, 6; IX, 8).
Probably the author intended to suggest both meanings. Most
translators take the meaning to be metaphysical, but Telang may be
right in taking it as ethical: Krishna is regarded as the ideal of
Action Yoga. For a similar use of the personal pronoun compare
_sarvakarmāni mayi sannyasya_ (XVIII, 57) with _sarvakarmāni
sannyasya_ of the _Paramahansopanishad_. Pages 706, 708 and 709 of
Jacob’s _Concordance to the Principal Upanishads and Bhagavadgītā_ are
peculiarly instructive in this connection.
Footnote 104:
IV, 14; IX, 9.
Footnote 105:
X, 12, 20.
Footnote 106:
III, 3; IV, 36-38; XII, 12.
Footnote 107:
XII, 12; XIII, 24.
Footnote 108:
II, 47-53; III, 7, 30; IV, 14-23; V, 2; VI, 1; XII, 12; XVIII, 1-11.
Footnote 109:
VII, 13-14; XII, 20.
Footnote 110:
VII, 15; IX, 11-12; XVI, 6-20.
Footnote 111:
II, 61; VII, 14; XII, 6; XVIII, 57.
Footnote 112:
XII, 2.
Footnote 113:
VI, 14, 31; IX, 13-14, 22, 30, 34; X, 8-10; XII, 2, 6-7, 14.
Footnote 114:
IV, 10; VII, 1, 29; IX, 32.
Footnote 115:
VI, 14; X, 9; XVIII, 57-58.
Footnote 116:
VIII, 5, 7, 14.
Footnote 117:
X, 3; XVIII, 66.
Footnote 118:
IV, 14; IX, 28; XVIII, 49.
Footnote 119:
V, 29; VI, 15; XVIII, 62.
Footnote 120:
X, 11.
Footnote 121:
VI, 15; VIII, 15.
Footnote 122:
IV, 9; VII, 19; VIII, 5, 7, 15-16; IX, 25, 28, 32, 34; XII, 8; XIII,
18; XIV, 2; XVIII, 55-56, 62, 65.
Footnote 123:
X, 2.
Footnote 124:
X, 1-3, 20.
Footnote 125:
IX, 23.
Footnote 126:
VII, 21-22.
Footnote 127:
IX, 29.
Footnote 128:
IX, 22; X, 7-11.
CHAPTER II.
PLATO’S JUST MAN.
We must now leave the land of Bhārata and seek the shores of Greece.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account