Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in EnglishGoethe, Johann Wolfgang von
History
Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in English
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von
Art; Literature -- History and criticism
Apparently they now had the essentials of poetry before them, but it
had further to be taken into consideration that the marvelous may
be barren and without human interest. This human interest which is
indispensable must be moral, and would then obviously tend to the
improvement of man; hence that poem would fulfil its ultimate aim which
in addition to its merits possessed utility. It was the fulfilment of
all these demands which constituted the test they wished to apply to
the various kinds of poetry, and that species which imitated nature,
and furthermore was marvelous, and at the same time moral in purpose
and effect, they placed first and highest. And after much deliberation
this great preëminence was finally ascribed, with the utmost
conviction, to Æsop’s fables!
Strange as such a deduction may now appear, it had the most decided
influence on the best minds. That Gellert and subsequently Lichtwer
devoted themselves to this department of literature, that even Lessing
attempted to do work in it, that so many others applied their talents
to it, speaks for the faith they put in this species of poetry. Theory
and practice always act upon each other; one can see from men’s works
what opinions they hold; and, from their opinions, it is possible to
predict what they will do.
Yet we must not dismiss our Swiss theory without doing it justice.
Bodmer, with all the pains he took, remained in theory and practice a
child all his life. Breitinger was an able, learned, sagacious man,
who, after making a careful survey, recognized all the requirements
to be fulfilled by a poem; in fact, it can be shown that he was dimly
conscious of the deficiencies of his method. Noteworthy, for instance,
is his query, whether a certain descriptive poem by König, on the
_Review Camp of Augustus the Second_, is properly speaking a poem;
and the answer to it displays good sense. But it may serve for his
complete justification that, after starting on a wrong track and nearly
completing his circle, he yet discovers the main issue, and at the end
of his book, as a kind of supplement, feels it incumbent on him to urge
the representation of manners, character, passions, in short the inner
man--which surely constitutes the chief theme of poetry.
It may well be imagined into what perplexity young minds were thrown by
such maxims torn from their contexts, half-understood laws, and random
dogmas. We clung to examples, and there, too, were no better off: the
foreign as well as the classical ones were too remote from us; behind
the best native ones always lurked a distinct individuality, the good
points of which we could not arrogate to ourselves, and into the faults
of which we could not but be afraid of falling. For any one conscious
of productive power it was a desperate condition.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account