Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in EnglishGoethe, Johann Wolfgang von
History
Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in English
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von
Art; Literature -- History and criticism
The choice of subject is one of the happiest that can be imagined,--men
struggling with dangerous animals, and animals that do not act as a
mass of concentrated force, but with divided powers; that do not rush
in at one side, nor offer a combined resistance, but capable by their
prolonged organization of paralyzing without injuring them, three
men, or more or less. From the action of this numbing force results,
consistently with the most violent action, a pervading unity and repose
throughout the whole. The different action of the serpents is exhibited
in gradation. The one is simply twined around its victims, the other
becomes irritated and bites its antagonist. The three figures are in
like manner most wisely selected: a strong, well-developed man, but
evidently past the age of greatest energy, and therefore less able to
endure pain and suffering. Substitute in his place a robust young man
and the charm of the group vanishes. Joined with him in his suffering
are two boys, small in proportion to his figure; again still two
natures susceptible of pain.
The struggles of the youngest are powerless; he is frightened, but
not injured. The father struggles powerfully, but ineffectually; his
efforts have rather the effect to exasperate the opposed force. His
opponent, becoming irritated, wounds him. The eldest son is least
encumbered. He suffers neither anguish nor pain; he is frightened
by the sudden wounding of his father, and his movement thereupon; he
cries out, at the same moment endeavoring to free his foot from the
serpent’s fold. Here then is spectator, witness, and accessory to the
fact; and thus the work is completed. Let me here repeat what I alluded
to above,--that all three figures exhibit a twofold action, and thus
are occupied in most manifold ways. The youngest son strives to free
himself by raising his right arm, and with his left hand keeps back
the serpent’s head; he is striving to alleviate the present, and avert
the greater, evil,--the highest degree of action he can attain in his
present imprisoned condition. The father is striving to shake off the
serpents, while his body recoils from the immediate bite. The oldest
son is terrified by his father’s starting, and seeks at the same time
to free himself from the lightly entwining serpent.
The choice of the highest moment of expression has already been spoken
of as a great advantage possessed by this work of art; let us now
consider this problem in greater detail.
We assumed the case of natural serpents twining about a father sleeping
by his sons, so that in considering the separate moments, we might be
led to a climax of interest. The first moments of the serpents’ winding
about them in sleep are portentous, but not significant for art. We
might perhaps imagine an infant Hercules asleep, with a serpent twined
about him; but in this case the form in repose would show us what we
were to expect when he waked.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account