Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in English — John Shaqi
Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in EnglishGoethe, Johann Wolfgang von
History
Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in English
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von
Art; Literature -- History and criticism
Let us now proceed and figure to ourselves a father with his children,
when first--let it have happened how it may--he discovers the
serpents wound about him. There is only one moment of the highest
interest,--when one of the figures is made defenseless by the pressure,
the second can still fight, but is wounded, the third still retains
a hope of escape. In the first condition is the younger son; in the
second, the father; in the third, the eldest son. Seek now to find
another, a fourth condition! Try to change the order of the _dramatis
personae_!
If we now consider the treatment from the beginning, we must
acknowledge that it has reached the highest point; and in like manner,
if we reflect upon the succeeding moments, we shall perceive that
the whole group must necessarily be changed, and that no moment can
be found equal to this in artistic significance. The youngest son
will either be suffocated by the entwining serpent, or should he in
his helpless condition exasperate it, he must be bitten. Neither
alternative could we endure, since they suppose an extremity unsuitable
for representation. As to the father, he would either be bitten by the
serpent in other places, whereby the position of the body would be
entirely changed and the previous wounds would either be lost to the
beholder or, if made evident, would be loathsome, or the serpent might
turn about and assail the eldest son, whose attention would then be
turned to himself,--the scene loses its participator, the last glimpse
of hope disappears from the group, the situation is no longer tragical,
it is fearful. The figure of the father, which is now self-centred in
its greatness and its suffering, would in that case be turned towards
the son and become a sympathizing subordinate.
Man has, for his own and others’ sufferings, only three sorts of
sensations, apprehension, terror, and compassion,--the anxious
foreseeing of an approaching evil, the unexpected realization of
present pain, and sympathy with existing or past suffering; all three
are excited by and exhibited in the present work, and in the most
fitting gradations.
Plastic art, laboring always for a single point of time, in choosing a
subject expressive of pathos will seize one that awakens terror; while
Poetry prefers such as excite apprehension and compassion. In the group
of Laocoon the suffering of the father awakens terror, and that in the
highest degree. Sculpture has done her utmost for him, but, partly to
run through the circle of human sensations, partly to soften the effect
of so much of the terrible, it excites pity for the younger son, and
apprehension for the elder, through the hope that still exists for
him. Thus, by means of variety, the artists have introduced a certain
balance into their work, have softened and heightened effect by other
effects, and completed at once a spiritual and sensuous whole.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account