Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in EnglishGoethe, Johann Wolfgang von
History
Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in English
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von
Art; Literature -- History and criticism
“I am not afraid of you,” said Wilhelm; “only hear me. In the
composition of this play, after the most accurate investigation and
the most mature reflection, I distinguish two classes of objects. The
first are the grand internal relations of the persons and events, the
powerful effects which arise from the characters and proceedings of the
main figures: these, I hold, are individually excellent; and the order
in which they are presented cannot be improved. No kind of interference
must be suffered to destroy them, or even essentially to change their
form. These are the things which stamp themselves deep into the
soul, which all men long to see, which no one dares to meddle with.
Accordingly, I understand, they have almost wholly been retained in
all our German theatres. But our countrymen have erred, in my opinion,
with regard to the second class of objects, which may be observed
in this tragedy: I allude to the external relations of the persons,
whereby they are brought from place to place, or combined in various
ways, by certain accidental incidents. These they have looked upon as
very unimportant; have spoken of them only in passing, or left them out
altogether. Now, indeed, it must be owned, these threads are slack and
slender; yet they run through the entire piece, and bind together much
that would otherwise fall asunder, and does actually fall asunder, when
you cut them off, and imagine you have done enough and more, if you
have left the ends hanging.
“Among these external relations I include the disturbances in Norway,
the war with young Fortinbras, the embassy to his uncle, the settling
of that feud, the march of young Fortinbras to Poland, and his coming
back at the end; of the same sort are Horatio’s return from Wittenberg,
Hamlet’s wish to go thither, the journey of Laertes to France, his
return, the despatch of Hamlet into England, his capture by pirates,
the death of the two courtiers by the letter which they carried. All
these circumstances and events would be very fit for expanding and
lengthening a novel; but here they injure exceedingly the unity of the
piece, particularly as the hero has no plan, and are, in consequence,
entirely out of place.”
“For once in the right!” cried Serlo.
“Do not interrupt me,” answered Wilhelm; “perhaps you will not always
think me right. These errors are like temporary props of an edifice:
they must not be removed till we have built a firm wall in their stead.
My project, therefore, is not at all to change those first-mentioned
grand situations, or at least as much as possible to spare them, both
collectively and individually; but with respect to these external,
single, dissipated, and dissipating motives, to cast them all at once
away, and substitute a solitary one instead of them.”
“And this?” inquired Serlo, springing up from his recumbent posture.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account