Half Hours With Modern Scientists: Lectures and EssaysTyndall, John
Philosophy
Half Hours With Modern Scientists: Lectures and Essays
Tyndall, John
Science
We also notice that it is very difficult, if not impossible, for the
inquisitive scientist to limit himself strictly to the object-matter of
his own chosen field, and not to enquire more or less earnestly—not
infrequently to dogmatize more or less positively—respecting the results
of other sciences and even respecting the foundations and processes of
scientific inquiry itself. Thus Mr. Huxley in the first Essay of this
Series on _The Physical Basis of Life_, leaves the discussion of his
appropriate theme in order to deliver sundry very positive and
pronounced assertions respecting the “limits of philosophical inquiry,”
and quotes with manifest satisfaction a dictum of David Hume that is
sufficiently dogmatic and positive, as to what these limits are. In more
than one of his Lay sermons, he rushes headlong into the most pronounced
assertions in respect to the nature of matter and of spirit. The
eloquent Tyndall, in No. 5, expounds at length _The Methods and
Tendencies of Physical Investigation_ and discourses eloquently, if
occasionally somewhat poetically, of _The Scientific use of the
Imagination_. But Messrs. Huxley and Tyndall are eminent examples of
scientists who are severely and successfully devoted respectively to
physiology and the higher physics. No one will contend that they have
not faithfully cultivated their appropriate fields of inquiry. The fact
that neither can be content to confine himself within his special field,
forcibly illustrates the tendency of every modern science to concern
itself with its relations to its neighbors, and the unresistible
necessity which forces the most rigid physicist to become a
metaphysician in spite of himself. So much for the appellation
“_Scientists_.”
“_Half Hours_” suggests the very natural inquiry—What can a scientist
communicate in half an hour, especially to a reader who may be ignorant
of the elements of the science which he would expound? Does not the
phrase _Half Hours with Modern Scientists_ stultify itself and suggest
the folly of any attempt to treat of science with effect in a series of
essays? In reply we would ask the attention of the reader to the
following considerations.
The tendency is universal among the scientific men of all nations, to
present the principles of science in such brief summaries or statements
as may bring them within the reach of common readers. The tendency
indicates that there is a large body of readers who are so far
instructed in the elements of science as to be able to understand these
summaries. In England, Germany, France and this country such brief
essays are abundant, either in the form of contributions to popular and
scientific journals, or in that of popular lectures, or in that of brief
manuals, or of monographs on separate topics; especially such topics as
are novel, or are interesting to the public for their theoretic
brilliancy, or their applications to industry and art.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account