In a history of biology Buffon is naturally a more important figure
than Montesquieu. Buffon had imbibed evolutionary views from the
_Protogæa_ of Leibnitz, which in turn made use of certain hypotheses
of Descartes.[19] The _Histoire Naturelle_ inclines to some theory of
evolution, especially in the later volumes. At first Buffon teaches
that species are fixed and wholly independent of one another; some
years later he is ready to believe that all quadrupeds may be derived
from some forty original forms, while in a third and subsequent passage
he puts the question whether all vertebrates may not have had a common
ancestor. He does not shrink from saying that one general plan of
structure pervades the whole animal kingdom—a belief that he could
never have adequately supported by facts; Baer long afterwards (1828)
searched in vain for evidence on this very point, while Darwin in
1859 admitted that his arguments and facts only proved common descent
for each separate phylum of the animal kingdom;[20] he inferred _from
analogy_ that probably all the organic beings which have ever lived on
this earth have descended from some one primordial form.[21] Elsewhere
Buffon makes bold to declare that Nature in her youthful vigour threw
off a number of experimental forms of life, some of which were approved
and adopted, while others were allowed to survive in order to give
mankind a wider conception of her projects. There is generally some
gleam of truth in Buffon's most fantastic speculations, but we often
wish that he could have attended to the warning of Bossuet: "Le plus
grand dérèglement de l'esprit est de croire les choses parce qu'on veut
qu'elles soient."
[Illustration: GEORGES LOUIS LECLERC, COMTE DE BUFFON.]
Against all his shortcomings we must set the fact that Buffon strove
to interpret the present by the past, the past by the present, geology
by astronomy, geographical distribution by the physical history of the
continents. One of his maxims expresses the fundamental thought of
Lyell's _Principles of Geology_: "Pour juger de ce qui est arrivé,
et même de ce qui arrivera, nous n'avons qu'à examiner ce qui arrive."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account