History of English Literature Volume 3 (of 3)Taine, Hippolyte
History
History of English Literature Volume 3 (of 3)
Taine, Hippolyte
English literature -- History and criticism
I cross seven leagues of sea, and here I am in a great unadorned hall,
with a multitude of benches, with gas burners, swept, orderly, a
debating club or a preaching-house. There are five hundred long faces,
gloomy and subdued;[267] and at the first glance it is clear that they
are not there to amuse themselves. In this land a grosser mood,
overcharged with a heavier and stronger nourishment, has deprived
impressions of their swift nobility, and thought, less facile and
prompt, has lost its vivacity and its gayety. If we rail before them, we
must think that we are speaking to attentive, concentrated men, capable
of durable and profound sensations, incapable of changeable and sudden
emotion. Those immobile and contracted faces will preserve the same
attitude; they resist fleeting and half-formed smiles; they cannot
unbend; and their laughter is a convulsion as stiff as their gravity.
Let us not skim over our subject, but lay stress upon it; let us not
pass over it lightly, but impress it; let us not dally, but strike; be
assured that we must vehemently move vehement passions, and that shocks
are needed to set these nerves in motion. Let us also not forget that
our hearers are practical minds, lovers of the useful; that they come
here to be taught; that we owe them solid truths; that their
common-sense, somewhat contracted, does not fall in with hazardous
extemporizations or doubtful hints; that they demand worked-out
refutations and complete explanations; and that if they have paid to
come in, it was to hear advice which they might apply, and satire
founded on proof. Their mood requires strong emotions; their mind asks
for precise demonstrations. To satisfy their mood, we must not merely
scratch, but torture vice; to satisfy their mind, we must not rail in
sallies, but by arguments. One word more: down there, in the midst of
the assembly, behold that gilded, splendid book, resting royally on a
velvet cushion. It is the Bible: around it there are fifty moralists,
who awhile ago met at the theatre and pelted an actor off the stage,
with apples, who was guilty of having the wife of a citizen for his
mistress. If with our finger-tip, with all the compliments and disguises
in the world, we touch a single sacred leaf, or the smallest moral
conventionalism, immediately fifty hands will fasten themselves on our
coat collar and put us out at the door. With Englishmen we must be
English, with their passion and their common-sense adopt their
leading-strings. Thus confined to recognize truths, satire will become
more bitter, and will add the weight of public belief to the pressure of
logic and the force of indignation.
Section III.--Superiority of Thackeray as a Satirist.--Literary Snobs
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account