[403] Thucyd. vii, 9. ἐν ἄλλαις πολλαῖς ἐπιστολαῖς. The word
_despatches_, which I use to translate ἐπιστολαῖς, is not
inapplicable to oral, as well as to written messages, and thus
retains the ambiguity involved in the original; for ἐπιστολαῖς,
though usually implying, does not necessarily imply, _written_
communications.
The words of Thucydidês (vii, 8) _may_ certainly be construed
to imply that Nikias had never on any previous occasion sent a
written communication to Athens; and so Dr. Thirlwall understands
them, though not without hesitation (Hist. Gr. ch. xxvi, vol.
iii, p. 418). At the same time, I think them reconcilable with
the supposition that Nikias may previously have sent written
despatches, though much shorter than the present, leaving details
and particulars to be supplied by the officer who carried them.
Mr. Mitford states the direct reverse of that which Dr. Thirlwall
understands: “Nicias had used the precaution of frequently
sending despatches in writing, with an exact account of every
transaction.” (Ch. xviii, sect v, vol. iv, p. 100.)
Certainly, the statement of Thucydidês does not imply this.
“Be not shocked when I tell you, that they intend to become
aggressors even at sea. They know well, that our fleet was at first
in high condition, with dry ships[404] and excellent crews; but
now the ships have rotted, from remaining too long at sea, and the
crews are ruined. Nor have we the means of hauling our ships ashore
to refit, since the enemy’s fleet, equal or superior in numbers,
always appears on the point of attacking us. We see them in constant
practice, and they can choose their own moment for attack. Moreover,
they can keep their ships high and dry more than we can; for they
are not engaged in maintaining watch upon others; while to us, who
are obliged to retain all our fleet on guard, nothing less than
prodigious superiority of number could insure the like facility. And
were we to relax ever so little in our vigilance, we should no longer
be sure of our supplies, which we bring in even now with difficulty
close under their walls.
[404] It seems, that in Greek ship-building, moist and unseasoned
wood was preferred, from the facility of bending it into the
proper shape (Theophrastus, Hist. Plant. v, 7, 4).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account