History of Spanish Literature, vol. 3 (of 3)Ticknor, George
History
History of Spanish Literature, vol. 3 (of 3)
Ticknor, George
Spanish literature -- History and criticism
[112] “Marcos de Obregon” has been occasionally a good deal
discussed, both by those who have read it and those who have not,
from the use Le Sage has been supposed to have made of it in
the composition of Gil Blas. The charge was first announced by
Voltaire, who had personal reasons to dislike Le Sage, and who,
in his “Siècle de Louis XIV.,” (1752,) said, boldly enough, that
“The Gil Blas is taken entirely from the Spanish romance entitled
‘La Vidad de lo Escudiero Dom Marcos d’Obrego.’” (Œuvres, ed.
Beaumarchais, Paris, 1785, 8vo, Tom. XX. p. 155.) This is one of
the remarks Voltaire sometimes hazarded, with little knowledge
of the matter he was discussing, and it is not true. That Le
Sage had seen the “Marcos de Obregon” there can be no doubt; and
none that he made some use of it in the composition of the Gil
Blas. This is apparent at once by the story which constitutes its
Preface, and which is taken from a similar story in the Prólogo
to the Spanish romance; and it is no less plain frequently
afterwards, in the body of the work, where the trick played on
the vanity of Gil Blas, as he is going to Salamanca, (Lib. I.
c. 2,) is substantially the same with that played on Marcos,
(Relacion I. Desc. 9,)--where the stories of Camilla (Gil Blas,
Liv. I. c. 16, Marcos, Rel. III. Desc. 8) and of Mergellina
(Gil Blas, Liv. II. c. 7, Marcos, Rel. I. Desc. 3), with many
other matters of less consequence, correspond in a manner not
to be mistaken. But this was the way with Le Sage, who has used
Estevanillo Gonzalez, Guevara, Roxas, Antonio de Mendoza, and
others, with no more ceremony. He seemed, too, to care very
little about concealment, for one of the personages in his Gil
Blas is called Marcos de Obregon. But the idea that the Gil Blas
was _taken entirely_ from the Marcos de Obregon of Espinel, or
was very seriously indebted to that work, is absurd. See the next
Period, Chap. IV., note on Father Isla.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account