The case may be put even more strongly. In war it often happens that
a man is shot through the arm in such a way that a part of a nerve
controlling the muscles of certain fingers is destroyed. The fingers
thereupon become paralysed; but when a surgeon fills up the gap in the
nerve by inserting a piece of nerve taken freshly from a slaughtered
calf the brain finds itself once more able to send its messages to
the muscles, and the man finds he can move his fingers. Absolute
proof thus exists that the brain and the fingers are distinct and
separate entities; and it would be utterly unscientific to infer that
the observed paralysis indicates necessarily any disappearance of, or
change in, the brain. What really occurs is merely that the brain is
deprived, for the time being, of one of the tools it is in the habit of
using for the purpose of exercising its authority over the body.
Consider, too, what takes place when a man has a “stroke,” as it is
termed--an apoplectic fit, the breaking of a small blood-vessel in
the brain. The exuded blood forms a clot which presses upon some of
the brain-cells and interferes with the normality of their action. In
some cases the cells affected are those that influence the organs of
speech. The man becomes dumb or cannot pronounce correctly. He has the
will to speak in his ordinary manner and he makes desperate efforts to
do so. These remain unavailing until the blood-clot becomes absorbed
and ceases to interfere with the brain-cells; and then the man’s will
is once more able to exert its authority over the latter, which, in
their turn, are once more able to organise and send forward the desired
impulses to the tongue, lips, etc. Absolute proof thus exists that the
will and the brain are distinct and separate entities; and it would
be utterly unscientific to infer that the observed pressure on, and
paralysis of, the brain-cells indicates any disappearance of, or change
in, the will.
But the will is comprised in the something that is commonly called
the “soul.” We see, then, that the existence of the soul and body as
distinct and separate entities is admitted by Science and demonstrated
by the everyday experience of mankind.
It is desirable, however, to add a word or two respecting a phrase and
an idea correlated thereto which have long exercised a mischievous
influence in psychics and psychology. The phrase is that “thought may
possibly be a secretion of the brain.” The idea is that although body
and mind (or soul) are separate entities neither of them can exist
separately from the other.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account