Humphry Davy, Poet and PhilosopherThorpe, T. E. (Thomas Edward)
Science
Humphry Davy, Poet and Philosopher
Thorpe, T. E. (Thomas Edward)
Davy, Humphry, Sir, 1778-1829
Nor were the experiments with muriatic acid more decisive.
Incidentally he obtained the two chlorides of phosphorus, but for a
time their true nature escaped him, although he gives a fairly accurate
description of their main properties.
The paper, although containing an account of much experimental work,
was evidently put together in haste; it would have been better for
his reputation had he delayed its publication. He seems to have been
conscious of its imperfections, and to have sought to strengthen his
conclusions by new experiments which he gives in an appendix. These,
so far from substantiating his views, increased his doubts, and it
is remarkable how he misinterpreted the phenomena he observed. Thus
in one series of experiments he obtained considerable quantities of
the “alcohol of sulphur of Lampadius,” and attempted to ascertain its
nature, but his preconceptions as to the non-elementary nature of
carbon and sulphur prevented him from recognising that it is a sulphide
of carbon.
One explanation of this untoward haste is to be found in the position
in which Davy was placed. He simply _hungered_ for scientific fame,
and his appetite grew by what it fed on. There was at the time
the most intense spirit of rivalry between the English and French
chemists--it was a phase of the national feeling which actuated the
two peoples--and, in spite of his phrases, Davy keenly felt what he
considered an intrusion into his own field of work. His illness had
thrown him back, and the French chemists had stolen a march on him
in the meantime. Moreover, he had Berzelius on his flank. All these
circumstances, whilst they impelled him to activity, were unfavourable
in a man of Davy’s temperament to the incubatory period, “the wambling
in the wame” process, which is often needed before the true aspect and
meaning of things are perceived; and there is no doubt that the fear
of being anticipated urged him to the expression of hypotheses and
surmises which at a later and calmer period he regretted and renounced.
But such was his position in England at this period, that a Bakerian
lecture seemed to be expected from him at each succeeding session of
the Royal Society as a matter of course, and he was always ready to
respond to the expectation, even if he did not invariably satisfy it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account