Illustrations of the Huttonian Theory of the EarthPlayfair, John
Science
Illustrations of the Huttonian Theory of the Earth
Playfair, John
Geology; Hutton, James, 1726-1797. Theory of the earth
This ingenious mineralogist, observing the interposition of the basalt
between stratified rocks, so that it had not only regular beds of
sandstone for its base, but was also covered with beds of the same
kind, saw plainly that these appearances were inconsistent with the
supposition of common volcanic explosions at the surface. He therefore
conceived, that the volcanic eruption had happened at the bottom of
the sea, (the level of which, in former ages, had been much higher
than at present,) and that the materials afterwards deposited on the
lava, had been in length of time consolidated into beds of stone. It
is evident, that this notion of submarine volcanoes, comes very near,
in many respects, to Dr Hutton's explanation of the same appearances.
If the only thing to be accounted for were the phenomenon in question,
it cannot be denied that Dolomieu's hypothesis would be perfectly
sufficient; but Dr Hutton, to whom this phenomenon was familiar, and
who, like Dolomieu, conceived the basalt to have been in fusion, was
convinced that the retreat of the sea was not a fact well attested by
geological appearances, and if admitted, was inadequate to account for
the facts usually explained by it. He conceived, therefore, that such
lava as the preceding had flowed not only at the bottom of the sea,
but in the bowels of the earth, and having been forced up through the
fissures of rocks already formed, had heaved up some of these rocks,
and interposed itself between them. This agrees with the other facts in
the natural history both of the basaltes and the strata.
It is plain, that, in this, there is a great approach of the two
theories to one another: both maintain the igneous origin of basaltes,
and its affinity to lava; both acknowledge that this lava cannot have
flowed at the surface, and that the strata which cover it have been
formed at the bottom of the sea. They only differ as to the mode in
which the submarine or subterraneous volcano produced its effect, and
that difference arises merely from the one geologist having generalized
more than the other. Dolomieu sought to connect the basalt with the
lavas that proceed from volcanic explosions at the surface; Dr Hutton
sought not only to connect these two appearances with one another, but
also with the other phenomena of mineralogy, particularly with the
veins of basaltes, and the elevation of the strata.
455. In another point, the coincidence of Dolomieu's opinions and Dr
Hutton's is still more striking. The former has remarked, that many
of the extinguished volcanoes are in granite countries, and that,
nevertheless, the lavas that they have erupted contain no granitic
stones. There must be, therefore, says he, something under the granite,
and this last is not, at least in all cases, to be considered as the
basis of the mineral kingdom, or as the body on which all others rest.
In this system, therefore, granite is not always a primordial rock, any
more than in Dr Hutton's.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account