Independence Day : $b its celebration, spirit and significance as related in prose and verse
History
Independence Day : $b its celebration, spirit and significance as related in prose and verse
Fourth of July -- Poetry; Fourth of July celebrations; Fourth of July orations
Until quite recently all historians have, consciously or unconsciously,
been consistent in misrepresenting the War of Seventy-Six and the events
leading thereto. And we owe no small debt of gratitude to writers like
Mr. Owen Wister and Mr. Sydney George Fisher for telling us the truth.
Mr. Wister writes[1] of the Revolution that while “As a war, its real
military aspect is slowly emerging from the myth of uninterrupted
patriotism and glory, universally taught to school children, its
political hue is still thickly painted and varnished over by our writers.
“How many Americans know, for instance, that England was at first
extremely lenient to us? fought us (until 1778) with one hand in a
glove, and an olive branch in the other? had any wish rather than
to crush us; had no wish save to argue us back into the fold, and
enforce argument with an occasional victory not followed up?... For any
American historian to speak the truth on these matters is a very recent
phenomenon, their common design having been to leave out any facts which
spoil the political picture of the Revolution they chose to paint for
our edification: a ferocious, blood-shot tyrant on the one side, and
on the other a compact band of ‘Fathers,’ down-trodden and martyred,
yet with impeccable linen and bland legs. A wrong conception even of
the Declaration of Independence as Jefferson’s original invention still
prevails; Jefferson merely drafted the document, expressing ideas well
established in the contemporary air. Let us suppose that some leader of
our own time were to write: ‘Three dangers to-day threaten the United
States, any one of which could be fatal: unscrupulous capital, destroying
man’s liberty to compete; unscrupulous Labor, destroying man’s liberty to
work; and undesirable Immigration, in which four years of naturalization
are not going to counteract four hundred years of heredity. Unless the
people check all of these, American liberty will become extinct.’ If
some one were to write a new Declaration of Independence, containing such
sentences, he could not claim originality for them; he would be merely
stating ideas that are among us everywhere. This is what Jefferson did,
writing his sentences loosely, because the ideas they expressed were so
familiar as to render exact definitions needless.”
Mr. Wister deserves gratitude for giving us these unpalatable truths
in such palatable form; but he should have far more gratitude for
introducing to a wide body of readers his chief source of information,
the historian Mr. Sydney George Fisher, one of whose most valuable
chapters has fortunately been secured for reproduction in the body of
this book. Mr. Fisher writes:[2]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account