Soviet Union -- History -- Revolution, 1917-1921 -- Personal narratives; World War, 1914-1918 -- Soviet Union
What will happen next in that distracted country? Into what new morass
are the people being led? Frankly, I do not know. I do not know anybody
who does. The only analogous situation in modern history is that of the
Poland of the eighteenth century. Poland had a government quite as bad
as that of the Russian Soviets, or Council of Workmen’s and Soldiers’
Delegates. Instead of being an all-socialist affair Poland’s parliament
was made up entirely of noblemen. These men were so proud, so “free”
in the New Russia sense of the word that they wouldn’t yield on any
question even to a majority vote. A single dissenting voice in their
parliament was enough to kill any measure. The people of Poland had no
more to say about government than the middle class and the rich have
in the Russia of to-day. And when a European war on a limited scale
broke out, and Frederick the Great started the era of frightfulness
which William the last thought he could bring to a triumphant
conclusion, the three great eastern powers of Europe--Russia, Prussia
and Austria--sliced up Poland and handed each of the three monarchs
a piece. Maria Theresa, who ruled the Austria of that day, wanted it
printed in the records that she wept when she took her piece, but she
took it just the same, and Poland has wept ever since.
This could happen to Russia. She could be dismembered and handed
around. But this is not likely to happen. The Allies would never be
so foolish or so cruel as to permit it to happen. Russia could fall
apart and become an aggregation of small separate states, but each one
of those would still have its Soviets, and consequently a government
without stability or permanence. Finland and the Ukraine are two
Russian states which are trying to bring about this end, and they may
succeed, but a dissected Russia would furnish such good material for
future wars that the Allies can hardly afford to consent to it.
Civil war is a fine possibility in Russia just now, except that there
seems to be no one at hand to organize the two forces. The strongest
probability is more guerilla warfare, more street fighting, more
motor trucks loaded with machine guns rushing up and down Petrograd,
more battle, murder and sudden death, and then the reaction. Just
what form the reaction will take nobody knows. But the mad Bolsheviki
know that it is coming, and though they almost court it they also
fear it. They call this inevitable reaction the counter revolution,
and they excuse all their vagaries, their obstinacy, their pig-headed
resistance to a coalition with non-socialists on the ground that
they are fighting the counter revolution. I have heard Americans in
Russia, college professors, business men, correspondents, even members
of American commissions, say: “Don’t blame these people too much for
their radicalism. They are afraid they will lose all they gained by the
revolution. They fear the return of autocracy.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account