Irish ImpressionsChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
History
Irish Impressions
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Ireland -- Civilization; Irish question
There was an old joke of my childhood, to the effect that men might
be grouped together with reference to their Christian names. I have
forgotten the cases then under consideration; but contemporary
examples would be sufficiently suggestive to-day. A ceremonial
brotherhood-in-arms between Father Bernard Vaughan and Mr Bernard Shaw
seems full of possibilities. I am faintly pleased with the fancy of Mr
Arnold Bennett endeavouring to extract the larger humanities of fiction
from the political differences of Mr Arnold White and Mr Arnold Lupton.
I should pass my own days in the exclusive society of Professor Gilbert
Murray and Sir Gilbert Parker; whom I can conceive as differing on
some points from each other, and on some points from me. Now there is
one odd thing to notice about this old joke; that it might have been
taken in a more serious spirit, though in a saner style, in a yet older
period. This fantasy of the Victorian Age might easily have been a
fact of the Middle Ages. There would have been nothing abnormal in the
moral atmosphere of mediævalism in some feast or pageant celebrating
the fellowship of men who had the same patron saint. It seems mad and
meaningless now, because the meaning of Christian names has been lost.
They have fallen into a kind of chaos and oblivion which is highly
typical of our time. I mean that there are still fashions in them,
but no longer reasons for them. For a fashion is a custom without a
cause. A fashion is a custom to which men cannot get accustomed; simply
because it is without a cause. That is why our industrial societies,
touching every topic from the cosmos to the coat-collars, are merely
swept by a succession of modes which are merely moods. They are customs
that fail to be customary. And so amid all our fashions in Christian
names, we have forgotten all that was meant by the custom of Christian
names. We have forgotten all the original facts about a Christian name;
but, above all, the fact that it was Christian.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account