Irish ImpressionsChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
History
Irish Impressions
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Ireland -- Civilization; Irish question
In all the Ulster propaganda I came across, I think the thing that
struck me most sharply was one phrase in one Unionist leading article.
It was something that might fairly be called Scottish; something
which was really even more Irish; but something which could not in
the wildest mood be called English, and therefore could not with any
rational meaning be called Unionist. Yet it was part of a passionately
sincere, and indeed truly human and historic outburst of the politics
of the north-east corner, against the politics of the rest of Ireland.
Most of us remember that Sir Edward Carson put into the Government a
legal friend of his named Campbell; it was at the beginning of the war,
and few of us thought anything of the matter except that it was stupid
to give posts to Carsonites at the most delicate crisis of the cause
in Ireland. Since then, as we also know, the same Campbell has shown
himself a sensible man, which I should translate as a practical Home
Ruler; but which is anyhow something more than what is generally meant
by a Carsonite. I entertain, myself, a profound suspicion that Carson
also would very much like to be something more than a Carsonite. But
however this may be, his legal friend of whom I speak made an excellent
speech, containing some concession to Irish popular sentiment. As might
have been expected, there were furious denunciations of him in the
press of the Orange party; but not more furious than might have been
found in the _Morning Post_ or any Tory paper. Nevertheless, there
was one phrase that I certainly never saw in the _Morning Post_ or
the _Saturday Review_; one phrase I should never expect to see in any
English paper, though I might very probably see it in a Scotch paper.
It was this sentence, that was read to me from the leading article of
a paper in Belfast: ‘There never was treason yet but a Campbell was
at the bottom of it.’ I give the extract as it was given to me; I
am quite conscious of a curious historical paradox about it. A curse
against Campbells would seem to be a Jacobite rather than a Williamite
tradition. It may suggest interesting complications of Scottish feuds
in Ireland; but it serves as one of a thousand cases of this fact about
the family.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account