Irish ImpressionsChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
History
Irish Impressions
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Ireland -- Civilization; Irish question
But if the fancy of a punster, following his own
delightful vein of nonsense, should see something quaint in the image
of a hundred such Kettles singing as he sang by a hundred hearths, a
more bitter jester, reading that black and obscure story of the capture
on the coast, might utter a similar flippancy about other Casements,
opening on the foam of such very perilous seas, in a land so truly
forlorn. But even if we were not annoyed at the pun, we should be
surprised at the plural. And our surprise would be the measure of the
deepest difference between England and Ireland. To express it in the
same idle imagery, it would be the fact that even a casement is a part
of a house, as a kettle is a part of a household. Every word in Irish
is a household word.
The English would no more have thought of a plural for the word
Gladstone than for the word God. They would never have imagined
Disraeli compassed about with a great cloud of Disraelis; it would
have seemed to them altogether too apocalyptic an exaggeration of
being on the side of the angels. To this day in England, as I have
reason to know, it is regarded as a rabid and insane form of religious
persecution to suggest that a Jew very probably comes of a Jewish
family. In short, the modern English, while their rulers are willing
to give due consideration to Eugenics as a reasonable opportunity for
various forms of polygamy and infanticide, are drifting farther and
farther from the only consideration of Eugenics that could possibly be
fit for Christian men, the consideration of it as an accomplished fact.
I have spoken of infanticide; but indeed the ethic involved is rather
that of parricide and matricide. To my own taste, the present tendency
of social reform would seem to consist of destroying all traces of the
parents, in order to study the heredity of the children. But I do not
here ask the reader to accept my own tastes or even opinions about
these things; I only bear witness to an objective fact about a foreign
country. It can be summed up by saying that Parnell is the Parnell for
the English; but a Parnell for the Irish.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account