Irish ImpressionsChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
History
Irish Impressions
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Ireland -- Civilization; Irish question
As a matter of fact, the great Dublin Strike, a conflagration of
which the embers were still glowing at the time of my visit, involved
another episode which illustrates once again this recurrent principle
of the reality of the family in Ireland. Some English Socialists, it
may be remembered, moved by an honourable pity for the poor families
starving during the strike, made a proposal for taking the children
away and feeding them properly in England. I should have thought the
more natural course would have been to give money or food to the
parents. But the philanthropists, being English and being Socialists,
probably had a trust in what is called organisation and a distrust
of what is called charity. It is supposed that charity makes a man
dependent; though in fact charity makes him independent, as compared
with the dreary dependence usually produced by organisation. Charity
gives property, and therefore liberty. There is manifestly much more
emancipation in giving a beggar a shilling to spend, than in sending
an official after him to spend it for him. The Socialists, however,
had placidly arranged for the deportation of all the poor children,
when they found themselves, to their astonishment, confronted with the
red-hot reality called the religion of Ireland. The priests and the
families of the faithful organised themselves for a furious agitation,
on the ground that the faith would be lost in foreign and heretical
homes. They were not satisfied with the assurance, which some of the
Socialists earnestly offered, that the faith would not be tampered
with; and, as a matter of clear thinking, I think they were quite
right. Those who offer such a reassurance have never thought about what
a religion is. They entertain the extraordinary idea that religion is
a topic. They think religion is a thing like radishes, which can be
avoided throughout a particular conversation with a particular person,
whom the mention of a radish may convulse with anger or agony. But a
religion is simply the world a man inhabits. In practice, a Socialist
living in Liverpool would not know when he was or was not tampering
with the religion of a child born in Louth. If I were given the
complete control of an infant Parsee (which is fortunately unlikely)
I should not have the remotest notion of when I was most vitally
reflecting on the Parsee system. But common sense, and a comprehension
of the meaning of a coherent philosophy, would lead me to suspect
that I was reflecting on it every other minute. But I mention the
matter here, not in order to enter into any of these disputes, but to
give yet another example of the way in which the essentially domestic
organisation of Ireland will always rise in rebellion against any
other organisation. There is something of a parable in the tales of
the old evictions, in which the whole family was besieged and resisted
together and the mothers emptied boiling kettles on the besiegers;
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account