Irish ImpressionsChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
History
Irish Impressions
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Ireland -- Civilization; Irish question
The extraordinary story of how that chance was lost may find mention
on a later page. I will begin by touching on the first incident that
befell me personally in connection with the same enterprise. I went to
Ireland at the request of Irish friends who were working warmly for
the Allied cause, and who conceived (I fear in far too flattering a
spirit) that I might at least be useful as an Englishman who had always
sympathised as warmly with the Irish cause. I am under no illusions
that I should ever be efficient at such work in any case; and under
the circumstances I had no great hopes of doing much, where men like
Sir Horace Plunkett and Captain Stephen Gwynne, far more competent,
more self-sacrificing, and more well-informed than I, could already
do comparatively little. It was too late. A hundredth part of the
brilliant constancy and tragic labours of these men might easily, at
the beginning of the war, have given us a great Irish army. I need not
explain the motives that made me do the little I could do; they were
the same that at that moment made millions of better men do masses of
better work. Physical accident prevented my being useful in France,
and a sort of psychological accident seemed to suggest that I might
possibly be useful in Ireland; but I did not see myself as a very
serious figure in either field. Nothing could be serious in such a case
except perhaps a conviction; and at least my conviction about the great
war has never wavered by a hair. _Delenda est_--and it is typical of
the power of Berlin that one must break off for want of a Latin name
for it. Being an Englishman, I hoped primarily to help England; but
not being a congenital idiot, I did not primarily ask an Irishman to
help England. There was obviously something much more reasonable to
ask him to do. I hope I should in any case have done my best for my
own country. But the cause was more than any country; in a sense it
was too good for any country. The Allies were more right than they
realised. Nay, they hardly had a right to be so right as they were.
The modern Babylon of capitalistic States was hardly worthy to go on
such a crusade against the heathen; as perhaps decadent Byzantium was
hardly worthy to defend the Cross against the Crescent. But we are glad
that it did defend the Cross against the Crescent. Nobody is sorry
that Sobieski relieved Vienna; nobody wishes that Alfred had not won
in Wessex. The cause that conquered is the only cause that survived.
We see now that its enemy was not a cause but a chaos; and that is
what history will say of the strange and recent boiling up of barbaric
imperialism, a whirlpool whose hollow centre was Berlin. This is where
the extreme Irish were really wrong; perhaps really wrong for the first
time, I entirely sympathise with their being in revolt against the
British Government. I am in revolt in most ways against the British
Government myself. But politics are a fugitive thing in the face of
history.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account