Irish ImpressionsChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
History
Irish Impressions
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Ireland -- Civilization; Irish question
Does anybody want to be fixed for ever on the wrong side at
the Battle of Marathon, through a quarrel with some Archon whose very
name is forgotten? Does anybody want to be remembered as a friend of
Attila, through a breach of friendship with Aëtius? In any case, it
was with a profound conviction that if Prussia won Europe must perish,
and that if Europe perished England and Ireland must perish together,
that I went to Dublin in those dark days of the last year of the war;
and it so happened that the first occasion when I was called upon for
any expression of opinion was at a very pleasant luncheon party given
to the representatives of the British Dominions, who were then on an
official tour in the country inspecting its conditions. What I said is
of no importance except as leading up to later events; but it may be
noted that though I was speaking perhaps indirectly to Irishmen, I was
speaking directly, if not to Englishmen, at least to men in the more
English tradition of the majority of the Colonies. I was speaking, if
not to Unionists, at least largely to Imperialists.
Now I have forgotten, I am happy to say, the particular speech that
I made, but I can repeat the upshot of it here, not only as part of
the argument, but as part of the story. The line I took generally in
Ireland was an appeal to the Irish principle, yet the reverse of a mere
approval of the Irish action, or inaction. It postulated that while the
English had missed a great opportunity of justifying themselves to the
Irish, the Irish had also missed a similar opportunity of justifying
themselves to the English. But it specially emphasised this; that what
had been lost was not primarily a justification against England, but
a joke against England. I pointed out that an Irishman missing a joke
against an Englishman was a tragedy, like a lost battle. And there was
one thing, and one thing only, which had stopped the Irishman from
laughing and saved the Englishman from being laughable. The one and
only thing that rescued England from ridicule was Sinn Fein. Or, at any
rate, that element in Sinn Fein which was pro-German, or refused to be
anti-German. Nothing imaginable under the stars _except_ a pro-German
Irishman could at that moment have saved the face of a (very recently)
pro-German Englishman.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account