Irish ImpressionsChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
History
Irish Impressions
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Ireland -- Civilization; Irish question
The reason for this is obvious enough. England in 1914 encountered
or discovered a colossal crime of Prussianised Germany. But England
could not discover the German crime without discovering the English
blunder. The blunder was, of course, a perfectly plain historical fact;
that England made Prussia. England was the historic, highly civilised
western state, with Roman foundations and chivalric memories; Prussia
was originally a petty and boorish principality used by England and
Austria in the long struggle against the greatness of France. Now in
that long struggle Ireland had always been on the side of France.
She had only to go on being on the side of France, and the Latin
tradition generally, to behold her own truth triumph over her own
enemies. In a word, it was not a question of whether Ireland should
become anti-German, but merely of whether she should _continue_ to be
anti-German. It was a question of whether she should suddenly become
pro-German, at the moment when most other pro-Germans were discovering
that she had been justified all along. But England, at the beginning
of her last and most lamentable quarrel with Ireland, was by no means
in so strong a controversial position. England was right; but she
could only prove she was right by proving she was wrong. In one sense,
and with all respect to her right action in the matter, she had to be
ridiculous in order to be right.
But the joke against the English was even more obvious and topical.
And as mine was only meant for a light speech after a friendly lunch,
I took the joke in its lightest and most fanciful form, and touched
chiefly on the fantastic theory of the Teuton as the master of the
Celt. For the supreme joke was this: that the Englishman has not only
boasted of being an Englishman; he has actually boasted of being a
German. As the modern mind began to doubt the superiority of Calvinism
to Catholicism, all English books, papers, and speeches were filled
more and more with a Teutonism which substituted a racial for a
religious superiority. It was felt to be a more modern and even a more
progressive principle of distinction, to insist on ethnology rather
than theology; for ethnology was supposed to be a science. Unionism
was simply founded on Teutonism. Hence the ordinary honest patriotic
Unionist was in a highly humorous fix when he had suddenly to begin
denouncing Teutonism as mere terrorism. If all superiority belonged
to the Teuton, the supreme superiority must clearly belong to the
most Teutonic Teuton. If I claim the right to kick Mr Bernard Shaw on
the specific ground that I am fatter than he is, it is obvious that I
look rather a fool if I am suddenly kicked by somebody who is fatter
still. When the earth shakes under the advancing form of one coming
against me out of the east who is fatter than I (for I called upon
the Irish imagination to embrace so monstrous a vision), it is clear
that whatever my relations to the rest of the world, in my relations
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account