Isabel of Castile and the making of the Spanish nation, 1451-1504Plunket, Ierne L. (Ierne Lifford)
History
Isabel of Castile and the making of the Spanish nation, 1451-1504
Plunket, Ierne L. (Ierne Lifford)
Isabella I, Queen of Spain, 1451-1504; Spain -- History -- Ferdinand and Isabella, 1479-1516
The Queen, we are told, “did not consider the undertaking very certain.”
Here spoke her habitual caution, prompted by a life in which the demands
on her assistance perpetually outran not her interest but her resources;
yet it is evident from the first the project caught her fancy, while in
Ferdinand it merely aroused a cold distrust. The country was scarcely
pacified from the anarchy of civil war and foreign invasion; national
credit and patriotism were strained to the uttermost in what, it had
become evident, must be a prolonged struggle against the Moors; the
French were threatening his own loved kingdom of Aragon, and he could
spare neither time nor money to regain command of the eastern Pyrenees;
insidious heresy was sapping the Catholic Faith, and wide care and
organization would be required for its suppression. Was this the moment
to take up chimerical schemes for reaching China or discovering lands
that every man of common-sense or culture had long believed to be
fabulous?
His arguments, somewhat to this effect, can be imagined, uttered with a
dry, logical force, not without its appeal to Isabel’s own logical
brain. She could see it all from his point of view, her reason accept
his conclusion; and yet deep in her nature was a power that
differentiated her statesmanship from his, and that in a crisis prompted
her, in the teeth of the logic that ordinarily governed her actions, to
run what has been happily called a “divine risk.”
If Ferdinand lacked the visionary instinct that made Isabel recognize
the Genoese sailor, not as adventurer or fool, but as a possible genius,
it must be confessed that in his case faith would have made greater
demands. Castile and Aragon were united into a single Spain, but it is
reading history from a modern outlook to suppose the individual
sympathies of King and Queen Spanish rather than distinctively Aragonese
and Castilian.
Throughout past centuries, as we have remarked before, the magnet of
Aragonese attraction had been the Mediterranean; and Ferdinand was no
less under its spell than his uncle, Alfonso V., the conqueror of
Naples. It required an effort to turn his mental gaze westwards; whereas
Isabel, heiress of Castilian hopes and ambitions, was imbued with the
spirit of rivalry with Portugal and looked on the “sea of darkness” not
with bored aloofness but with awed speculation. It might well seem that
its secrets held no immediate prospects for Aragon; they were pregnant
with possibilities of empire and wealth for the sister kingdom with her
Galician and Andalusian seaboard. It is thus that both by character and
race Isabel and not her husband was destined to be Columbus’s true
patron, and that looking back over years of probation he could write
later:
In all men there was disbelief; but to the Queen, my lady, God gave
the spirit of understanding and great courage, and made her heiress of
all as a dear and much-loved daughter.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account