Lectures on ancient ethnography and geography, volume 1 (of 2) : $b comprising Greece and her colonies, Epirus, Macedonia, Illyricum, Italy, Gaul, Spain, Britain, the north of Africa, etc.Niebuhr, Barthold Georg
History
Lectures on ancient ethnography and geography, volume 1 (of 2) : $b comprising Greece and her colonies, Epirus, Macedonia, Illyricum, Italy, Gaul, Spain, Britain, the north of Africa, etc.
Niebuhr, Barthold Georg
Ethnology; Geography, Ancient; History, Ancient
which is the designation of Thessaly. Argos, even in the opinion of many
ancients, was only the name of a country. I am convinced, therefore,
that, in the early times, it was nothing but the name of the country, and
that, as the name of the city, it is of later origin. Just as Corinth was
in reality newly built by the Dorians, and ought not, therefore, to be
mentioned here, so Argos also was founded by Dorian settlers at a time
when Mycenae and Tiryns had already fallen from their former eminence.
Throughout all mythology, Tiryns alone is the capital of Diomedes and
Sthenelus, and Mycenae that of the Atreids; these two cities alone
are mentioned, no third ever occurs, and Argos is not spoken of until
the Doric migration and conquest. In this manner it is clear that the
tragedians, who, however, generally were not learned men, do not deserve
the reproach which the Alexandrian grammarians made against them; as, for
example, that Sophocles confounded Argos and Mycenae. Mycenae, before
the existence of Argos, was a true Argos[11], the capital of the whole
country, though by no means identical with the later Argos.[12] In this
manner the outlines of those kingdoms acquire a more suitable shape: the
Acte, or the eastern part of Argolis, was distinct from Argos Proper
even at that time, just as it was afterwards; the capitals, Tiryns and
Mycenae, were still near enough to each other. When, accordingly, the
grammarians found such contradictions as in Sophocles, they endeavoured
to mediate by means of more recent myths, or even by inventing new ones,
and that often in the most singular manner. The whole story, for example,
how Diomedes was forced to go to Italy, and how Sthenelus gave up his
kingdom, arose only from the circumstance, that in later and seemingly
better historical authorities, the statement was found that the capital
of Tiryns was united with the kingdom of Agamemnon; and the difficulty
of accounting for the manner in which that kingdom had disappeared, was
removed by a fiction.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account