Now, in so far as our conscious mental activity is under the direction
of our will, we can improve this form of common sense, as to both its
range and the trustworthiness of its judgments, by appropriate training.
Such training, as regards the purely intellectual aspect of common
sense, will consist in the determinate culture of the habit of honestly
seeking for truth,--dismissing prejudice, setting aside self-interest,
searching out all that can be urged on each side of the question at
issue, endeavouring to assign to every fact and argument its real value,
and then weighing the two aggregates against each other with judicial
impartiality. For in proportion to the steadiness with which this course
is volitionally pursued, must be its effectiveness in shaping the
mechanism whose automatic action constitutes the unconscious thinking,
of which the results express themselves in our common-sense judgments.
The ordinary common sense of mankind, disciplined and enlarged by an
appropriate culture, becomes one of the most valuable instruments of
scientific inquiry; affording in many instances the best and sometimes
the only basis for a rational conclusion. A typical case, in which no
special knowledge is required, is afforded by the flint implements of
the Abbeville and Amiens gravel beds. No logical proof can be adduced
that the peculiar shapes of these flints were given to them by human
hands; but no unprejudiced person who has examined them now doubts it.
The evidence of design to which, after an examination of one or two such
specimens, we should only be justified in attaching a probable value,
derives an irresistible cogency from accumulation. On the other hand,
the improbability that these flints acquired their peculiar shape by
accident, becomes to our minds greater and greater as more and more such
specimens are found; until at last this hypothesis, although it cannot
be directly disproved, is felt to be almost inconceivable, except by
minds previously possessed by the dominant idea of the modern origin of
man. And thus what was in the first instance a matter of discussion, has
now become one of those self-evident propositions, which claim the
unhesitating assent of all whose opinion on the subject is entitled to
the least weight.
We proceed upwards, however, from such questions as the common sense of
mankind generally is competent to decide, to those in which special
knowledge is required to give value to the judgment; and here we must
distinguish between those departments of inquiry in which scientific
conclusions are arrived at by a process of strict reasoning, and those
in which they partake of the nature of common sense judgments.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account