Of the former class we have a typical example in mathematics, and in
those exact sciences which make use of mathematics as their instrument
of proof; but even in these, it is common sense which affords not only
the basis, but the materials of the fabric. For while the axioms of
geometry are self-evident truths which not only do not require proof,
but are not capable of being proved in all their universality, every
step of a demonstration is an assertion of which our acceptance depends
on our incapability of conceiving either the contrary or anything else
than the thing asserted. And thus the certain assurance of the proof
felt by every person capable of understanding a mathematical
demonstration, depends upon the conclusive self-evidence of each step of
it. But we not unfrequently meet with individuals, not deficient in
ordinary common sense, who cannot be brought to see this self-evidence;
whilst, on the other hand, the advanced mathematician, when adventuring
into new paths of inquiry, is able to take a great deal for granted as
self-evident, which at an earlier stage of his researches would not
have so presented itself to his mind. The deliverances of this acquired
intuition can in most cases be readily justified by the reasoning
process which they have anticipated. But the genius of a
mathematician--that is, his special aptitude developed by special
culture--will occasionally enable him to divine a truth, of which,
though he may be able to prove it experientially, neither he nor any
other can at the time furnish a logical demonstration. In this divining
power we have clear evidence of the existence of a capacity which cannot
be accounted for by the mere co-ordination of antecedent experiences,
whether of the individual or of the race; and yet, as already shown,
such co-ordination has furnished the stimulus to its development.
Of those departments of science, on the other hand, in which our
conclusions rest (like those of ordinary common sense) not on any one
set of experiences, but upon our unconscious co-ordination of the whole
aggregate of our experiences,--not on the conclusiveness of any one
train of reasoning, but on the convergence of all our lines of thought
towards one centre,--geology may be taken as a typical example. For this
inquiry brings (as it were) into one focus, the light afforded by a
great variety of studies,--physical and chemical, geographical and
biological; and throws it on the pages of that great stone book in which
the past history of our globe is recorded. And its real progress dates
from the time when that common sense method of interpretation came to
be generally adopted, which consists in seeking the explanation of past
changes in the forces at present in operation, instead of invoking (as
the older geologists were wont to do) the aid of extraordinary and
mysterious agencies.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account