Lives of the apostles of Jesus Christ — John Shaqi
Lives of the apostles of Jesus ChristBacon, David Francis
Religion
Lives of the apostles of Jesus Christ
Bacon, David Francis
Apostles
the name of Julias, in honor of Julia, daughter of Augustus
Caesar. This was done during the reign of Augustus, (Josephus,
in Jewish Antiquities book i. chapter 2, section 1,) and of
course long before Jesus Christ began his labors, though after
his birth, because it was after the death of Herod the Great.
The question now is, whether the Bethsaida mentioned by
the evangelists is by them so described as to be in any way
inconsistent with the account given by Josephus, of the place
to which he gives that name. The first difficulty which has
presented itself to the critical commentators, on this point, is
the fact, that the Bethsaida of the gospels is declared in them
to have been a city of Galilee, (John xii. 21,) and those who
were born and brought up in it are called Galileans, (Mark xiv.
70, Luke xxii. 59, Acts i. 7, ii. 7.) Yet Josephus expressly
tells us, that Bethsaida was in Gaulanitis, which was not in
Galilee, as he bounds it, but was beyond its eastern boundary,
on the eastern side of the river and lake. (Jewish war, book
xviii. chapter 2, section 1.) This is therefore considered by
many, as a diversity between the two accounts, which must make
it impossible to apply them both to the same place. But there
is no necessity for such a conclusion. The different application
of the term Galilee, in the two books, must be noticed, in
order to avoid confusion. Josephus is very exact in the use of
names of places and regions, defining geographical positions
and boundaries with a particularity truly admirable. Thus, in
mentioning the political divisions of Palestine, he gives the
precise limits of each, and uses their names, not in the loose,
popular way, but only in his own accurate sense. But the gospel
writers are characterized by no such minute particularity, in
the use of names, which they generally apply in the popular,
rather than the exact sense. Thus, in this case, they use the
term Galilee, in what seems to have been its common meaning in
Judea, as a name for all the region north of Samaria and Peraea,
on both sides of the Jordan, including, of course, Gaulanitis
and all the dominions of Philip. The difference between them and
Josephus, on this point, is very satisfactorily shown in another
passage. In Acts v. 37, Gamaliel, speaking of several persons
who had at different times disturbed the peace of the nation,
mentions one Judas, the _Galilean_, as a famous rebel. Now this
same person is very particularly described by Josephus, (Jewis
Antiquities book xv. chapter 1, section 1,) in such a manner
that there can be no doubt of his identity with the previous
description. Yet Josephus calls him distinctly, Judas the
_Gaulanite_, and only once Judas the _Galilean_; showing him
to have been from the city of Gamala, in the country east of
Jordan and the lake; so that the conclusion is unavoidable,
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account