Makers of ElectricityWalsh, James J. (James Joseph)
History
Makers of Electricity
Walsh, James J. (James Joseph)
Electricity -- Biography
That Bacon was no admirer of Gilbert's physical and cosmical theories
the following passages will show. In the "Novum Organum" the Chancellor
wrote: "His philosophy is an instance of extravagant speculation founded
on insufficient data"; again, "As the alchemists made a philosophy out
of a few experiments of the furnace, Gilbert, our countryman, hath made
a philosophy out of the lodestone" ("The Advancement of Learning");
lastly, "Gilbert hath attempted a general system on the magnet,
endeavoring to build a ship out of materials not sufficient to make the
rowing-pins of a boat" ("De Augmentis Scientiarum").
One is tempted to ask how this strange disregard which Bacon entertained
for the scientific views of the greatest natural philosopher of his age
and country came to exist? Was it due to a feeling of jealousy that
could not brook a rival in the domain of the higher philosophy, or was
it because Bacon, the anti-Copernican, wanted to write down Gilbert, the
defender of the heliocentric theory, in the British Isles?
When reading Bacon's depreciatory remarks we have to remember that his
mathematical and physical outfit was very limited even for the age in
which he lived; from which it is safe to infer that he was but little
qualified to pass judgment on the value of the electric and magnetic
work accomplished in the workshops at Colchester or on the theories to
which they gave rise.
Bacon deserves praise for denouncing the prevalent system of natural
philosophy which was mainly authoritative, speculative and syllogistic
instead of experimental, deductive and inductive, but he was
inconsistent and forgetful of his own principles when he belittled the
greatest living enemy of mere book-learning, and the most earnest
advocate, by word and example, of the laboratory methods for the
advancement of learning.
To avoid misapprehension, it should be here stated that Bacon was not
always censorious in his treatment of his illustrious fellow-citizen,
for in several places he writes approvingly of the electric and magnetic
experiments contained in _De Magnete_, which he calls in his
_Advancement of Learning_, "a painfull (_i.e._, painstaking)
experimentall booke." In other places he draws so freely on Gilbert
without acknowledgment as to come dangerously near the suspicion of
plagiarism.
Gilbert died, probably of the plague, in the sixtieth year of his age,
on December 10th, 1603, and was buried in the chancel of Holy Trinity
Church, Colchester, where a mural tablet records in Latin the chief
facts of his life.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account