Arthur Aikin’s _Annual Review_, vol. ii. (for 1803) pp. 292 _seq._ Cf. Southey’s _Life and Correspondence_ (ed. 1850), vol. ii. p. 251, 20th Jan. 1804: “Yesterday Malthus received, I trust, a mortal wound from my hand;” cf. vol. vi. p. 399, and vol. ii. p. 294. There is no hint of obligation to Coleridge. Footnote 867: Cf. above, ch. iii. pp. 81 _seq._, and Bk. III. Footnote 868: _Sic_, though it explains a thing by itself. Footnote 869: He probably meant 353rd, but his numbers are careless. Footnote 870: On margin of p. 364, 2nd paragr.: “Quote and apply to himself.” Footnote 871: _E. g._ on p. 65 opposite to lines 5, 6, “Ass!” a monosyllabic refinement omitted in Southey’s review. Footnote 872: First in 1817, 7th ed., pp. 509 _seq._ Footnote 873: One of the charges (p. 18: that Malthus recommends the same remedies as Condorcet) is sufficient to stamp the character of the book—_An Inquiry into the Principle of Population_, &c., by James Grahame. Its Introduction gives a useful list of writers on both sides; see p. 71. (Edin., 1816.) Simonin repeats Grahame’s charges, with more mistakes of his own. See his _Hist. de la Psychologie_ (1879), pp. 397–9. Footnote 874: 7th ed., p. 511. Cf. above, p. 52, and the reply to Godwin’s Reply, _Essay_, 2nd ed., III. iii. 384. Footnote 875: _Edinburgh Review_, Jan. 1837. Footnote 876: _Life and Correspondence of Southey_, vol. iii. pp. 21–2, and p. 188. Footnote 877: Bishop of Gloucester and later of Hereford. _Theolog. Works_ (1832). Footnote 878: “The prolificness of human things, otherwise similarly circumstanced, varies inversely as their numbers.”—Sadler, _Popn._, vol. iii. p. 352 (1830). Reviewed somewhat caustically by Macaulay in _Edin. Rev._, July 1830. See Trevelyan’s _Life of Macaulay_, vol. i. p. 126. Cf. Sadler’s ‘Reply’ to _Edin. Rev._ His weakest point was his use of “inversely.” Footnote 879: Malthus, _Essay_, II. v. (7th ed.), pp. 164, 166; cf. p. 485. Footnote 880: G. P. Scrope, M.P., _Pol. Econ._, 1833, &c. Malthus, _Essay_, III. iii. (7th ed.), 282–6 (Owen), IV. xii. 457 (Owen), III. xiv. 380 n. (Anderson). Footnote 881: John Weyland, junr., F.R.S. _The Principles of Population and Production as they are affected by the Progress of Society with a view to Moral and Political Consequences_, 1816. Footnote 882: So Arnold Toynbee, _Industrial Revolution_, p. 107. Footnote 883: Ch. iii. p. 21. He adds, as his second: “This tendency can never be destroyed.” Footnote 884: _Essay_, Appendix, p. 517. Footnote 885: Propos. iii and iv. Footnote 886: _Essay_, _l. c._ p. 521, a very strong passage. Footnote 887: Append. p. 526. Footnote 888: _Pop. and Prod._, pp. 82 _seq._ Footnote 889: 7th ed., I. ii. 12 n.; 2nd ed., p. 16. Footnote 890: _Tour in Southern Counties of England_, 1767, p. 342. Footnote 891: Between 1767 and 1820. Cf. above (England).