Francia, Francesco, approximately 1450-1517; Mantegna, Andrea, 1431-1506; Painters -- Italy -- Biography
The leading feature which marks the work of all Squarcione’s scholars,
and was to attain its highest artistic development in Mantegna’s later
conceptions, is the sculptural treatment of form, which was a direct
result of an exclusive study of ancient statues. Painting in their hands
becomes more plastic than pictorial, the forms are sharply defined,
the drapery falls in the small folds of ancient bas-relief, while the
severity of the whole is relieved by rich decorations in the shape of
festoons of fruit and foliage, which, when unskilfully managed, give a
heavy and over-loaded effect. This plastic tendency sprang from the
discovery, then first dawning upon the men of the Renaissance, that the
principles of the highest art are to be found in the antique, and was
so far as it went true and laudable in its aim. But in the case of the
Squarcionesques this study of classic statuary was not combined with
sufficient knowledge of nature, and, therefore, frequently degenerated
into a lifeless rigidity and absence of expression, if not into positive
ugliness and coarseness of form.
This stiffness and want of vitality strike us at once in the four
Evangelists on the ceiling of the chapel, wrongly ascribed by Vasari to
Mantegna, and in the upper frescoes of St. Christopher’s life, attributed
to three different artists—Marco Zoppo, Bono of Ferrara, and Ansuino of
Forli. These last-named subjects are not without a considerable degree
of skill in perspective and composition, but are alike marked by the
same rigidity of form and metallic coldness of colouring. The feeblest
of the three is Bono’s representation of St. Christopher bearing the
child through the river, a work which, in awkwardness, incorrect drawing
and truly painful ugliness, seems to exaggerate the worst faults of the
Paduan school.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account