Francia, Francesco, approximately 1450-1517; Mantegna, Andrea, 1431-1506; Painters -- Italy -- Biography
In the fresco of “St. James baptizing Converts” the statuesque air of
Squarcione’s school is still strongly felt in the principal figures. The
action is stiff, and the faces are mostly wanting in expression. But
the spectators of the ceremony are, on the contrary, full of life and
animation. Nothing can be more natural than the two children who look on
with wondering eyes—the taller of the two holding a water-melon in his
hand, while the smaller one presses close to his side—or the youth under
the colonnade in the act of turning round to speak to a figure whose face
is concealed by a pillar. If from these we turn to the decorative part of
the fresco, the winged angels in the upper corners at once remind us of
the charming groups of children on Donatello’s bronzes in Sant’ Antonio,
and prove how attentively Mantegna must have studied these recently
finished works of the Florentine master. The beneficial influence of
the great sculptor had already appeared in the earlier frescoes of the
Eremitani, and from his example Andrea now learnt how to combine the
study of nature with sculptural treatment, and to adopt a more elevated
type of human form.
The next subject, “St. James before Herod,” reveals a new feature,
afterwards to become prominent in his career, in the accurate knowledge
of Roman costumes and classical architecture which is here displayed. One
of the finest figures is that of a soldier leaning on his lance in the
left-hand corner of the picture, an ancient Roman, in whom we recognise
immediately the painter’s own portrait, from the close resemblance
which his strongly marked features and massive brow bear to the bust on
Andrea’s tomb at Mantua. Both of these frescoes show considerable skill
in perspective, but in the next, “St. James blessing a kneeling Disciple
on his way to Execution,” Mantegna boldly ventures on an experiment
that is altogether new. For no apparent reason, but purely as a trial
of skill, he suddenly alters the point of sight to a low level, and
while the feet of the foremost figures appear to stand on the edge of
the picture the lower extremities of those in the background vanish
altogether. The difficulties thus created are on the whole correctly
solved. Each figure is carefully foreshortened, and the Roman arch under
which the procession passes is drawn in admirable perspective, but
freedom of action is impaired, and the whole suffers from an unpleasant
sense of effort and unnatural constraint. Perspective was in those days
a favourite branch of learning in the University of Padua, and Mantegna,
whose vigorous genius took pleasure in the driest studies, seems to have
derived this strange passion for applying its laws to the human form from
Paolo Uccelli, a Florentine who had lately visited Padua. In his ardour
to accomplish his self-imposed task he failed to see the mistake of
subjecting living figures to the rules of architecture, and of treating
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account