Measure Your Mind: The Mentimeter and How to Use ItTrabue, Marion Rex
Science
Measure Your Mind: The Mentimeter and How to Use It
Trabue, Marion Rex
Educational tests and measurements; Intelligence tests; Psychological tests
In another camp 765 men of a regular infantry regiment, who had been
with their officers for several months, were graded by their officers in
five classes, according to their practical military value. Seventy-six
of these men were rated either A or B by the Alpha test; all but nine of
these had been graded “one” and “two” by their officers, and none of
them had been placed in the lowest grade.
Out of 238 of these soldiers who scored D or D, _minus_, in the
psychological test, all but eight had been placed in the three lowest
grades by their officers. The psychological ratings and the ratings of
the company commanders were identical in 49.5 per cent. of all cases. In
88.4 per cent. of the cases the agreement was within one step, and in
only seven tenths of 1 per cent. was there a disagreement between the
psychological test results and the officers’ ratings of more than two
steps.
Here is another comparison. Sixty company commanders each named his ten
best and ten poorest privates. Without any knowledge on the part of the
psychological examiners in this or in any other of the comparative tests
as to the ratings the officers had given the men, the Alpha gave the
grade of D or D, _minus_, to 57.5 per cent. of those picked as the
poorest and placed all but a fractional percentage of 1,118 men in the
same classes in which they had been placed by their officers on the
basis of observation and experience.
Those who failed in the Group tests were given individual attention by
the clinical psychologist. The examination here was frequently by the
Stanford Revision of the Binet test or by the Yerkes-Bridges Point
Scale. For men who could not understand the instructions and the
language necessary for taking these two tests a series of specially
devised performance tests, consisting chiefly of picture puzzles, cubes,
squares, crescents, and other forms cut from wood, were provided. The
assumption was that a man who has not intelligence enough to place a
triangular block in a perfectly obvious triangular hole, or to piece
together the six or seven parts which, when properly assembled, make up
the figure of a man or a ship is so hopelessly deficient mentally as to
be not only of no value, but a positive detriment to the Army. In many
instances fully grown men with the mentality of children seven or eight
years old were thus weeded out from among the recruits who had
successfully passed the physical tests and been inducted into the
service. Men making the D, _minus_, or E score in either the Alpha or
the Beta tests were graded as of very inferior intelligence; D, _minus_,
men were held to be fit for regular service but the E men were
recommended for service in the development battalions or for discharge.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account