Medicine and the Church: Being a series of studies on the relationship between the practice of medicine and the church's ministry to the sick — John Shaqi
Medicine and the Church: Being a series of studies on the relationship between the practice of medicine and the church's ministry to the sick
Religion
Medicine and the Church: Being a series of studies on the relationship between the practice of medicine and the church's ministry to the sick
Medicine -- Religious aspects; Pastoral medicine
Therefore, let the clergyman be content, for the present, to leave
the untrained practice of methods of suggestion to quacks; and
investigation of so-called cures to the medical profession. At the same
time, let the medical man avail himself of the services of the minister
of religion in cases in which exhortation is likely to be of use; for
in the field of functional nervous conditions, and slight mental
disturbances, the help of a priest of forceful character, reasonably
controlled, may be of great service.
In concluding this article a summary of the suggestions offered for
consideration may be made:
(1) The main function of the minister of religion should be concerned
with what is called the spiritual side of man, and not with purely
material conditions, such as disease.
(2) If ministers regard the Scriptures as imposing upon them duties
in healing the sick, they should be content to be subservient to
the physician in material conditions that are not included in their
training.
(3) In dealing with phenomena as specific as diseases, the Church
must be prepared to accept scientific explanations. It is useless to
complain of the materialism of doctors in connexion with material
physical disorders.
(4) It is not unlikely that the effects of spiritual healing will prove
to be merely results of a form of suggestion.
(5) Results that can be described as curative will be found, probably,
only in what are known as functional and neurotic conditions.
(6) It is most unwise to countenance untrained laymen in carrying on
spiritual healing in the name of the Church; for in the end the Church
may find herself dragged at the heels of quackery.
(7) While much can be done by ministers of religion in encouraging
sufferers from disease, or in distracting the attention of
neurasthenics, and while such assistance should be welcomed by medical
men, yet the Church should beware of attempting to attract believers
by means of thaumaturgic displays of healing, which are open to
explanation in other ways. The Church should not enter into competition
with bone-setters, osteopaths, physical culture quacks, and other
undesirable persons.
(8) Opinion on so-called ‘special powers’ should be suspended until
alleged instances of their existence have been thoroughly investigated
by competent trained experts.
THE PATIENT
BY
STEPHEN PAGET, F.R.C.S.
THE PATIENT
BY STEPHEN PAGET, F.R.C.S.
The Bishop of Birmingham wrote to me, last year, the following letter.
He gave me leave to publish it in the second edition of a book of mine
about Christian Science: and he gives me leave to publish it again here:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account